But why would light "slow down"? | Visualizing Feynman's lecture on the refractive index
Channel:3Blue1Brown · Length:28:33 · Published:2023-11-30 · Views:2899927
Summary
3Blue1Brown visualizes Feynman's lecture on the refractive index, explaining why light appears to slow down in glass and why the effect depends on color. It builds the idea from waves produced by oscillating charges in the material.
Why HN recommends it
HN considers it among the clearest accessible explanations of what refractive index actually is and how light moves through transparent matter.
probably the clearest reasonably accessible explanation of this topic anywhere to date — HN, 2023
Fundamental physics · Everyday physics & science demos
Subtitles (excerpt)
I realized recently that I didn't really understand how a prism works. The standard explanation, what you might hear in a high school physics class for example, goes something like this. When light enters a medium, like glass, it slows down, in the sense that if you look at the crests of the wave, in a vacuum those crests are traveling at c, the speed of light, but inside the glass those crests will be traveling a little bit slower. And the specific ratio between the speed of light in a vacuum and the speed inside a medium like this is called the index of refraction for that medium. The reason we use the word refraction instead of say the index of slowing is that if a beam of light enters this glass at an angle, then a consequence of this slowdown is that it bends a little bit, or using the lingo, it refracts. And the way my high school physics teacher always explained this was to imagine a tank going from some region where it can travel relatively quickly, like concrete, into something slower, like mud, where if it's coming in at an angle, then as one of its treads hits the slow region first, that tread will be going slower while the other one is faster, causing the whole tank to steer a little bit,
On Hacker News
For anyone who hasn't studied electrodynamics or advanced optics, Grant Sanderson (3Blue1Brown) recently made a detailed video explaining what the refractive index really means, probably the clearest reasonably accessible explanation of this topic anywhere to date: [VIDEO] [LINK] The first video is really a tour de force. Too bad it saw such limited traction here: [LINK] — jacobolus, 2023-12
Great article. For another fantastic explainer on optics, see 3Blue1Brown's video on refraction: [VIDEO] — _jayhack_, 2026-01
I'm not a physicist, but as far as I know, outside of general relativity electromagnetic perturbations always travel at the speed of light (i.e. to affirm that photons always travel at c is correct). It's only after the fields interact with electrical charges (atoms and their electrons for example) that a secondary field is induced as these charges begin to oscillate. This field will add over the… — tatjam, 2025-02
For those curious about what the above poster is talking about, here’s a well done video explaining the topic of the apparent changes of light’s “speed” through materials 3Blue1Brown - But why would light "slow down"? | Optics puzzles 3: [VIDEO] — Modified3019, 2024-04
I found this 3blue1brown video to be a fascinating explaination on how light gets transmitted by transparent material: [VIDEO] — ithkuil, 2024-01
Related videos
- Assholes are Ruining Your Project. Donnie Berkholz (RedMonk). · Tom Raftery · 18:03
- Strange Spheres in Higher Dimensions - Numberphile · Numberphile · 10:33
- CppCon 2017: Titus Winters “C++ as a "Live at Head" Language” · CppCon · 1:31:13
- Entanglement and Complexity: Gravity and Quantum Mechanics · Stanford Institute for Theoretical Physics · 1:14:24
- Leonard Susskind | "ER = EPR" or "What's Behind the Horizons of Black Holes?" - 1 of 2 · Stanford Institute for Theoretical Physics · 1:47:53
- Simplicity Ain't Easy - Stuart Halloway · ClojureTV · 50:00
- How Wrong Is VERITASIUM? A Lamp and Power Line Story · ElectroBOOM · 19:17
- Building the Moroccan Court · The Met · 17:44
- Times Tables, Mandelbrot and the Heart of Mathematics · Mathologer · 13:36
- Chinampas of Mexico: Most Productive Agriculture EVER? · Andrew Millison · 17:24
- Analogy as the Core of Cognition · Stanford · 1:08:37
- Diatoms: Tiny Factories You Can See From Space · Journey to the Microcosmos · 7:44
- The man with 1,000 Klein Bottles UNDER his house - Numberphile · Numberphile · 6:49
- Sorting Algorithms: Speed Is Found In The Minds of People - Andrei Alexandrescu - CppCon 2019 · CppCon · 1:29:55
- AT&T Archives: Similiarities of Wave Behavior (Bonus Edition) · AT&T Tech Channel · 28:02
- Heat Pumps: the Future of Home Heating · Technology Connections · 35:15