The Moon's Orbit is WEIRD

Channel:minutephysics · Length:5:29 · Published:2024-10-02 · Views:1932422

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A minutephysics explainer showing that the Moon's path around the Sun is not a spiral but closer to a 12-sided polygon with curved corners. It argues the Moon arguably orbits the Sun rather than the Earth.

Why HN recommends it

HN links it whenever the Moon's orbit comes up, as a concise explanation of why the Moon always curves toward the Sun.

I can't explain better than minute physics, highly recommend — HN, 2026

Cosmology & astrophysics · Space exploration & spaceflight · Everyday physics & science demos

Subtitles (excerpt)

We think of the moon as orbiting the earth, following a spiraling trajectory as the earth itself orbits the sun. But this is wrong. Not only is the moon's orbit NOT a spiral... there's an argument that the moon actually orbits the sun, not the earth! Sure, from the earth's perspective, the moon appears to orbit the earth. But from the sun's perspective (or from an observer far above the solar system), the moon orbits the earth so slowly and the earth and moon are so far from the sun that the moon's trajectory never actually makes any sort of a loop, and in fact, it never even curves outwards towards the earth but always inwards towards the sun! The moon's trajectory is more like a 12-sided polygon with curved corners than it is a spiral or even a wiggly line. Though the moon's trajectory is so close to being a circle it's kind of hard to see. Here's a simpler example of an orbit where a planet's moon's trajectory only ever curves towards its sun - it looks like this hypothetical moon is actually orbiting the sun and just getting nudged in and out a little bit by the planet as it orbits. This type of curve, where a circle rotates while attached to another rotating circle, is called an "epitrochoid," though they're usually

On Hacker News

Very cool! Just one note about the moon orbit around the Earth, it is far more subtle; almost just orbiting the Sun alongside Earth. I can't explain better than minute physics, highly recommend: [VIDEO] — lgcmo, 2026-06
This video explains what you’re talking about re the moons orbit always curving toward the sun, and also mentions Earths gravitational dominance. It’s about the suns gravitational pull on the moon dominating over the Earths gravitational pull on the moon, but that due to the centrifugal force (there isn’t one, so conservation of angular momentum) the Earth's gravitational pull dominates. [VIDEO] — nandomrumber, 2026-04
It’s arguable that even the stuff we consider to orbit the earth like the moon is really orbiting the sun. MinutePhysics did a great video on this: [VIDEO] — d1sxeyes, 2025-01
Minutephysics did a video about this: [VIDEO] It looks like a dodecagon with rounded corners, but the video goes into more details. — GuB-42, 2024-12

Related videos