Can You Trust Kurzgesagt Videos?

Channel:Kurzgesagt – In a Nutshell · Length:6:10 · Published:2019-03-03 · Views:7062596

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Kurzgesagt addresses whether viewers can trust its videos, describing its research process and how it handles older videos with errors or overstated claims.

Why HN recommends it

HN cites it when debating Kurzgesagt's credibility and its corrections and removals of earlier content.

They also vet their videos with experts and are transparent in their methodology — HN, 2020

Media, journalism & propaganda · Scientific method & science communication

Subtitles (excerpt)

Can you trust Kurzgesagt videos? To answer this question, we'll first explain how we research them and then talk a bit about past videos, and what we want to achieve with the channel. Making a Kurzgesagt video always begins with a question or an issue. For example, after our meat video, many viewers asked about the health effects of meat on humans. We had no idea, and were pretty curious too, so we just decided to work on it. The first step is research. We start by looking for books and scientific papers to get an overview, and just read a lot. The plan is to find a story worth telling. Is there something surprising to learn? Is there a larger context or a new perspective, or will it be an overview or introduction? Once we have the first readable version, we reach out to experts or scientists, and ask them to fact check and correct us. Often enough, they find a flaw or point us in the direction of contradictory research. At this point, many scripts die. If our idea does hold up, we continue working on it. This process can take weeks or months. Our Loneliness script, for example, took over a year and a half to finish. The hardest part is being brief, while not simplifying too much. It's much easier to write a long script than a short one.

On Hacker News

I believe they did it on this video called "Can You Trust Kurzgesagt?". They also removed a few of their older videos at the time because they had this exact issue of presenting as fact some things that were not at all certain. [VIDEO] — Dextro, 2022-05
> physical vs psychological dependence is kind of outdated I wouldn't say outdated, but I do agree it is 100% up for debate. Kurzgesagt did a really similar video[0] on addiction, but the basically walked it back from such a hard line stance in a correction/update video[1]. It's not so easy to tease apart the social vs the physical vs the pure mental. > Just the same, you can be addicted to coffe… — irjustin, 2022-03
> I think this explanation, as well as that from the video, is layman psychology at best Well, kurzgesagt back their statements with references to academic research: [LINK] They also vet their videos with experts and are transparent in their methodology: [VIDEO] > Yes, there are factors or mechanisms that drive your desire for belonging, but it is a pretty unconvincing observation. It doesn't hav… — CaptArmchair, 2020-09

Related videos