Why is Ukraine the West's Fault? Featuring John Mearsheimer

Channel:The University of Chicago · Length:1:14:15 · Published:2015-09-25 · Views:30454879

Watch on YouTube

Summary

University of Chicago lecture in which John Mearsheimer argues the West, through NATO and EU expansion, bears primary responsibility for the Ukraine crisis. He also discusses how to end it and its consequences.

Why HN recommends it

During 2022 HN threads, commenters shared it as the realist counter-perspective to understand the Russian position, though others dispute his record.

I find his viewpoint helpful as it’s very much Machiavellian and not focused on demonizing the Other. — HN, 2022

Geopolitics & foreign policy · University lectures & courses

Subtitles (excerpt)

All right am i uh am I on here oh okay great um good afternoon everyone welcome to the uncommon core lecture uh the causes and consequences of the ukraine crisis my name is michael volchak i attended the university from 1986 to 1991 i got a bachelor's in political science and a masters in international relations Professor Mearsheimer was a tremendous influence on my life um completely revolutionizing my worldview changed how i looked at international relations politics just everything in fact he was such a big influence on my life that whoops that when i went home for the summer between one of the school years leaving my college girlfriend here she gave me a little keepsake picture book and she said here to remember the people you love and inside was a picture of her on the right and a picture of professor mearsheimer on the left that's true story um uh when i was here the two biggest things that for me were uh military affairs and the model united nations of the university of chicago the student organization that i co-founded in 1988 and at that time i discovered that you need a faculty advisor in order to have a registered student organization um so of course i thought for about two seconds

On Hacker News

These anti disinformation posts are quite peculiar. I'd advise anyone who wants to dig deeper to listen to West Point graduate Mearsheimer: [VIDEO] It takes one hour to listen. Take notes and verify the facts afterwards. No disinformation there, much less Russian. — trehnert, 2024-11
John Mearscheimer said the same in 2016[1]. Stephen Cohen apparently said the same. They don't need to "take" Ukraine. They just want it as a buffer zone. The Q/A at the end of John Mearscheimers talk is actually quite interesting. Ukraine is not of vital interested to the West. If it had been they would have integrated it into NATO already. They tried the same with Georgia and right away Russia … — rjzzleep, 2022-03
> While there are no specific or credible cyber threats to the U.S. homeland at this time, Russia’s unprovoked attack on Ukraine, which has involved cyber-attacks on Ukrainian government and critical infrastructure organizations, may impact organizations both within and beyond the region. ... That word "unprovoked" is... loaded. Here's a definition: > (of an attack, or a display of aggression or … — Barrera, 2022-03
Thank you for your interesting line of thought. I do not know why you are downvoted - you have my upvote. I also think it is crucial to see the whole picture, and to take counter positions into account e.g. this [1] interesting talk by John Mearsheimer. It is not only Russia that lost its position in the world, the West has been playing contradictionary set of games in the last two decades as wel… — wuschel, 2022-03
I'm not "enlightened", and you can draw your own conclusions. But they don't have to annex Ukraine, they can just mess it up and cripple its military. At the least, Putin's stated aim is "demilitarization" of Ukraine. As for the comparison with the Baltic states, I would note that this entire situation evolved over decades. Perhaps Russia would have more strongly opposed NATO membership for the B… — Svettie, 2022-02

Related videos