Bret Weinstein on "The Portal" (w/ host Eric Weinstein), Ep. #019 - The Prediction and the DISC.

Channel:Eric Weinstein · Length:2:13:50 · Published:2020-02-20 · Views:705438

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A long Portal podcast episode in which Bret Weinstein tells Eric Weinstein the story of his lab mice telomere work, the prediction behind it, and what it means for science and aging.

Why HN recommends it

HN recommends it as the full account of the lab mice issue and evolutionary tradeoffs between cancer and longevity, despite its length.

an evolutionary biologist goes into depth about telomeres, evolution and how cancer and longevity are two sides of the same coin — HN, 2021

Evolution & genetics · Biology & biotechnology · Scientific method & science communication

Subtitles (excerpt)

hello this is Eric Weinstein I'm going to be recording a short introduction to this episode because I think it's probably the most important episode of the portal to date that said under normal circumstances I probably would have either edited this heavily or not released it at all it starts off quite slow and it gets quite awkward before finding its pace now what's going on is that the interview subject is none other than my brother Brett Weinstein in Brett's case you probably know him if you know him at all as the heroic professor who stood up against what can only be described I swear I'm not making this up as an Maoist insurrection at an American College in the Pacific Northwest the Evergreen State College it was a very strange situation because somehow the national media that we would normally have thought would have covered such a story for example the media that covered the takeover of straight Hall at Cornell in the 60s that media was almost absent completely at least they were absent for a very long time before they entered late in the game and why is that because the story ran counter narrative that is the students at the Evergreen State College who were behaving in a racist fashion were actually students

On Hacker News

I recommend the book: Rigor Mortis: How Sloppy Science Creates Worthless Cures, Crushes Hope, and Wastes Billions Generally, all scientific fields have immense issues related to the walled gardens and limitations created by their peers. I also recommend this discussion between Eric and Brett Weinstein which highlights just one example of the major issues: [VIDEO] — lettergram, 2021-10
The answer is yes. It seems the author is reasoning more in the philosophic realm than in evolutionary biology. In this podcast [1] an evolutionary biologist goes into depth about telomeres, evolution and how cancer and longevity are two sides of the same coin. Long story short, having cells die after a number of replications is a postive trade off. It means that when a cell replicates too fast i… — rvanlaar, 2021-07
Uh oh, mice in labs are not like humans in this regard at all. Lab Mice have extraordinary cell repair capabilities. My guess is that the AKG slows down cell division. This podcast delves into the problem with lab mice and explains the trade offs that happen on an evolutionary and cellular level in mice with regards to longevity. [VIDEO] — rvanlaar, 2020-09
According to Bret Weinstein who figured out the connection between telomere length and breeding, they seem to have quietly changed the breeding protocols to bring the telomere length back down to be in line with wild type mice. He talks about it in a long interview that gets really interesting about a hour in: [VIDEO] — bz33t, 2020-08
They go over multiple topics. Check the top comment for timestamps. If you want to hear the full story I suggest listening to this podcast episode: [VIDEO] . It's long, but I found it very interesting. — ZephyrBlu, 2020-07

Related videos