Why Some Diseases Only Traveled One Direction

Channel:CGP Grey · Length:11:12 · Published:2015-11-23 · Views:13945063

Watch on YouTube

Summary

CGP Grey explains why European diseases devastated the Americas while few deadly diseases traveled the other way. He ties it to livestock domestication, dense cities, and the ideas of Guns, Germs and Steel.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters point to it as a clear, short explanation of one-directional disease spread and the core argument of Guns, Germs, and Steel.

I think CGP Grey does a great job at communicating the actual meat of Guns, Germs, and Steel here — HN, 2019

World history · Medicine & infectious disease

Subtitles (excerpt)

Between the first Europeans arriving in 1492 and the Victorian age, the indigenous population of the New World dropped by at least 90%. The cause? Not the conquistadors and company -- they killed lots of people but their death count is nothing compared to what they brought with them: small pox, typhus, tuberculosis, influenza, bubonic plague, cholera, mumps, measles and more leapt from those first explorers to the costal tribes, then onward the microscopic invaders spread through a hemisphere of people with no defenses against them. Tens of millions died. These germs decided the fate of these battles long before the fighting started. Now ask yourself: why didn't the Europeans get sick? If New-Worlders were vulnerable to old-world diseases, then surely Old-Worlders would be vulnerable to New World diseases. Yet, there was no Americapox spreading eastward infecting Europe and cutting the population from 90 million to 9. Had Americapox existed it would have rather dampened European ability for transatlantic expansion. To answer why this didn't happen: we need first to distinguish regular diseases -- like the common cold -- from what we'll call plagues. 1. Spread quickly between people.

On Hacker News

Expanding on this, CGP Grey had this amazing video ( [VIDEO] ) of why European diseases in the Americas were so bad on the people that were already here when the two worlds met but you hardly heard of Europeans getting any super contagious illness from the people living in the Americas. Meaning European genomes had some adaptations (as well as antibodies?) from dense and unsanitary living, as wel… — bigmattystyles, 2022-10
> So any theory of "geographical stunting" would need to explain what changed in the geography after 1492. What changed was technology. Once you have ships going back and forth across the Atlantic, everything changes. Europeans introduced cows, sheep, pigs, chickens. The New World's only domesticable native animal is the llama, which is the main reason why civilizations sprung up in Central and t… — vinceguidry, 2015-11
[VIDEO] is a good watch here, if you're curious why Europeans didn't catch reciprocal plagues when traveling to the Americas. Spoiler: it's what the adjacent comment said, the Americas didn't have the factors for plagues. — akerl_, 2023-08
CGP Grey has a great video about this topic: Americapox: The Missing Plague - [VIDEO] TL;DR; You need big cities to keep plagues ongoing. — Hokusai, 2021-10
CPG Grey has a great video on this exact subject: [VIDEO] In short, you need cities to develop these types of viruses. Cities where the virus can just keep killing, without ever hitting a dead end. — seph-reed, 2021-10

Related videos