Why Vertical Farming Won't Save the Planet

Channel:Utah State University Extension · Length:46:48 · Published:2015-09-18 · Views:243601

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Utah State plant scientist Bruce Bugbee presents his analysis of the energy and environmental costs of vertical and indoor farming. He argues artificial lighting cannot compete with sunlight in fields or greenhouses.

Why HN recommends it

HN uses it as the go-to rebuttal to vertical farming hype, since it gives hard numbers from a leading controlled-environment authority.

he does give hard numbers to do the math that shows that vertical farming is not as good as its proponents have made it out to be — HN, 2025

Renewables, batteries & storage · Environment, agriculture & food systems

Subtitles (excerpt)

[MUSIC PLAYING] Astrid mentioned, I spent a big part of my career working with NASA and the controlled environments of space and we'd flown stuff on the shuttle many times. And as this issue of vertical farming started to heat up more and more and more magazine editors and journalists contacted me about what do you think about this. Is this going to work and what of their claims? And I started, there were so many. I had a canned response that I was sending them. Then this past summer, I was asked to speak at the Annual Meeting of the American Society for Horticultural Science on this topic. Now I gave a different talk there, but there's so many things to follow up on and refine that there's a great opportunity to do this again for this audience. Before I get into the details of this, I want to do a little sidebar. It's a three-slide sidebar and this is an article about 18 months ago in the New York Times, which I read every morning. Get it online. This got forwarded around campus at the time widely. Nicholas Kristof is a very widely known journalist for the times and he said professors, we need you. This is the headline of this story. Some of the smartest thinkers in the world are professors.

On Hacker News

[VIDEO] Been sending this video to every charlatan pushing vertical farming for years now. The math is pretty obvious and insurmountable on this one. — busterarm, 2023-12
Unsurprising. I'm not sure much has changed since this recording of Bruce Bugbee's talk "Why Vertical Farming Won't Save the Planet". There's nothing surprising there but he does give hard numbers to do the math that shows that vertical farming is not as good as its proponents have made it out to be. Solar energy input dwarfs all other energy inputs to agriculture, and the cost to replace one acr… — Shawnecy, 2025-03
This article is all over the place and then apparently quotes an academic out of context. The real problem with indoor farming is not setup cost. For the fundamentals: [VIDEO] ... Bruce Bugbee, Utah State University Department of Plants, Soils and Climate, has studied plant growth in controlled environments for most of his career presents the results of his analysis of the environmental effects o… — contingencies, 2018-10
Why Vertical Farming Won't Save the Planet [0] is a lecture by the preeminent authority in the field, Bruce Bugbee, Utah State University Department of Plants, Soils and Climate, who has studied plant growth in controlled environments for most of his career and has consulted on all NASA missions with these goals. In particular see 13m26s[1] and 37m17s[2]. [0] [VIDEO] [1] [VIDEO] [2] [VIDEO] — contingencies, 2018-07
A very informed and informative lecture filled with facts that supports the former argument: [VIDEO] Myself I am a chemical engineer working in agricultural research. We are working on aquaponics and also test vertical growbeds. Vertical growbeds underperform significantly unless you put expensive light on them. Generating the electricity for light through PV uses about ten times the area compare… — jsilence, 2017-01

Related videos