Why Every Japanese Criminal is Guilty

Channel:Rare Earth · Length:8:40 · Published:2019-12-07 · Views:2431438

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A Rare Earth explainer on Japan's criminal justice system and its extremely high conviction rate. It outlines the system's idiosyncrasies and how suspects are treated.

Why HN recommends it

HN cites it in threads about Japan's near-total conviction rate and what it says about the culture and legal system.

a recent Rare Earth video is Kafkaesque. — HN, 2019

Law, policing & justice · Social issues & culture

Subtitles (excerpt)

Crimmmmmme and punishment. It's more than just a boring book that I think everybody should read. It’s also the topic of today’s video. Because while many people know something about Japanese crime, specifically that its rates are low, very few know anything about its punishment. And Japanese punishment is among the harshest and most inescapable on the entire planet. Their prisons are notoriously draconian. And if you ever end up in their court system, there is near a one hundred percent change that you are going to be locked up. Which means one of two things: Either their penal system is perfect, or they’re locking up a lot of innocent people. If you find yourself before a Japanese criminal court, there’s upwards of a 99.98% chance that you’re going to be convicted. Those are higher numbers than places where justice is a farce. That's higher than Saudi Arabia. That's higher than China. Even Stalinist Russia didn’t put up those of numbers. To put it simply, if their legal system puts you before a judge, you’re going to be found guilty. But if you read interviews with certain members of the Japanese court, chances are you’ll walk away thinking they hadn’t locked up a single innocent person in their entire careers.

On Hacker News

Speaking of Japan, a recent Rare Earth video is Kafkaesque.[0] By contrast, the US has more prisoners per capita than Japan and more than all countries except the island nation of Seychelles. 0. Why Every (Accused) Japanese Criminal is Guilty. [VIDEO] — duelingjello, 2019-12
Japan has a strong culture of "don't rock the boat, be sure, very very sure if you accuse someone", and thus accusations are already sentences practically. Couple this with any kind of loyalty, and you immediately see that speaking up will get folks excommunicated (ronins, woah!) [VIDEO] So, probably they kept quiet on the first failed test, made it go away to save face, and then there was no goi… — pas, 2023-12
Or third or any-th world country. Big corps are big business, big money, big power. Germany is 6th on this list, Norway is 1st. Japan is 15th [0] and Hong Kong is 16th [1] the US is not in the top 20. [LINK] [0] [VIDEO] [1] nor for long :( — pas, 2021-06
There was also a recent "Rare Earth" episode about this: "Why Every Japanese Criminal is Guilty" - [VIDEO] — eliaspro, 2020-01

Related videos