The Hidden Rules of Conversation

Channel:Tom Scott · Length:5:32 · Published:2020-05-04 · Views:5829407

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Tom Scott explains Gricean maxims, the unwritten guidelines that shape how we understand each other. He uses examples such as why 'asbestos-free cereal' sounds suspicious.

Why HN recommends it

HN uses it as a short, clear explanation of implied meaning in conversation and the cooperative principle.

This video covers the concept pretty well — HN, 2023

Psychology & human behavior · Language & linguistics

Subtitles (excerpt)

“Vegan burgers” are a sensible thing to find on a supermarket shelf. But “vegan tomatoes” wouldn’t be. In fact, those tomatoes would sound a bit suspicious: it’s the same as the old joke about asbestos-free cereal. Those labels are ignoring one of Grice’s Maxims, a set of… guidelines that explain how we communicate with each other. Paul Grice was a philosopher of language, and in '75 he published a paper called "Logic and Conversation". He was dealing with the gap between natural language and what’s called “logical formalism”. Basically, we communicate far more than just the literal meaning of our words. Grice wrote that for that to be possible without having some hyper-logical unambiguous language, we must be operating under some shared assumptions, what he called the Cooperative Principle. We assume that we are cooperating with each other when we are talking. Which is obvious, right? But there's a deeper point there: we all try to fit what other people say into the context of what’s happening or what’s already been said. That's part of why, when we play a computer game and a character says exactly the same thing no matter if we’ve just saved their village or burned down their house,

On Hacker News

This video covers the concept pretty well: [VIDEO] It is pretty normal to try to incorporate the extranneous details into the reply. — jsight, 2023-09
I can play this game too: I never actually said they are a bad judge of what comments are botted, just merely suggested it as a possibility. Otherwise: [LINK] [VIDEO] Suffice to say, I'd thus kindly reject being a "bad comprehender of what words mean", thank you very much. It was a perfectly reasonable initial reading of their comment as far as I'm concerned. It's ambiguous. Happens. The fact tha… — perching_aix, 2026-05
Embracing Grice’s maxims may help here [0]? Being a pit of cynicism isn’t a particularly nuanced take, please do better than that. 0: [VIDEO] — clankyclanker, 2023-03
There are these things called Grice's Maxims of Conversation, and this one is called the "Maxim of Quantity." The extra unneeded information is strange because it would normally be assumed. Tom Scott's example[0] is "vegan tomato." Felt like sharing because it's kinda neat to see it described by someone in the wild. [0]: [VIDEO] — sli, 2021-06
> Ignorance is not an excuse. Taking it that you aren't trolling (which I'm not certain you aren't) ignorance is an excuse. It is not a good excuse when knowledge is common but it is a great excuse when knowledge is uncommon (as is the case here, at least to Americans). Unless you expect everyone to be omniscient then this is exceedingly disingenuous and will just lead to people thinking you're b… — godelski, 2021-01

Related videos