Living Computation: Robust-first programming in ULAM
Channel:Dave Ackley · Length:15:03 · Published:2015-09-08 · Views:3885
Summary
Dave Ackley presents robust-first computing and the ULAM programming language for the Movable Feast Machine, a cellular-automata-like architecture. It was a short video for the Future Programming Workshop 2015.
Why HN recommends it
HN points to it as an entry into Ackley's indefinitely scalable computing project, with a network-switch demo recommended as the best place to start.
I think the best place to start is this demo of a network switch made out of cells — HN, 2019
Programming language design · Computer architecture & CPUs
Subtitles (excerpt)
I'm Dave Ackley. I come out of artificial life, machine learning, and computer security. And all of that, especially computer security, pushed me into focusing on sort of how are we going to fix the computer mess that we've gotten ourselves into, as far as computer security. And what are we going to do when cache coherence runs out? So for the last seven years or so I've been looking at non-von Neumann -- post-von Neumann -- computer architectures and we've gotten some.. Programming is a first-class issue on top of this architecture, so I wanted to put some of these ideas before the Future Programming folk to seek allies and kindred spirits, or just to sharpen the pitch. So, when I think of the future of programming, to me there's really just one distinction to make, and that is: Does the programming still assume deterministic execution -- same inputs, same outputs -- or not? It seems clear to me that determinism of that style is a property of small computations, and what we've been doing so far are small computations by that view -- and the model is under stress, in fact. So when I think of the future of programming -- maybe not next week or next month, but in not that many years, mainly, it's going to be the case that programming
On Hacker News
I'll always upvote Dave Ackley. His vision for computing is so audacious it seems unbelievable. Global consistency? Don't need it! Determinism? An illusory safety blanket for wimps and suckers! Sure, everyone talks a big game about eventual consistency, but who's signing up to use an eventually consistent CPU? Dave freakin' Ackley, that's who. And the whole thing would sound like blue-sky bullshi… — sgentle, 2019-08
Me to, and I'm always battling with the LLM's obsession with lazily writing reams of ridiculously defensive code and masking errors in the code it generates and calls, instead of finding the root cause and solving that. (Yes, I'm referring to the code LLMs generate, not the API for generating code itself, but "fail early and spectacularly" should apply to all code and apis.) But you have to draw … — DonHopkins, 2025-07
More links. The underlying project for programming using Cellular Automata: [VIDEO] . Previously on HN: [LINK] There's a Youtube channel: [LINK] Sources: [LINK] Paper for city generation in particular: [LINK] — akkartik, 2019-07
There's also a more recent 'router' demo(1) that -- though still rigid and rectangular -- does build its own boundary rather than relying on the grid boundary. (1) [VIDEO] — daveackley, 2015-11
Related videos
- Code Monkey · spiffworld · 3:49
- Wild Tricks for Greenscreen in Blender · IanHubert · 9:50
- MC Frontalot - It Is Pitch Dark · MC Frontalot · 5:09
- Robust-first computing: Demon Horde Sort (full version) · Dave Ackley · 27:12
- Prejudice by Tim Minchin · Tim Minchin · 6:44
- Ted Nelson's Eulogy for Douglas Engelbart · Computer History Museum · 7:25
- Eric Bier Demonstrates Cedar · Computer History Museum · 1:56:07
- World Building in Blender - Ian Hubert · Blender · 35:44
- Unbelievably busy bicycle crossing in Amsterdam · Thomas Schlijper · 9:03
- Rich Harris - Rethinking reactivity · You Gotta Love Frontend · 36:45
- "Weird Al" Yankovic - Word Crimes (Official 4K Video) · alyankovicVEVO · 3:45
- Dasher: information-efficient text entry · Google TechTalks · 53:45
- Robust-first computing: Beyond efficiency · Dave Ackley · 14:46
- The Pervert's Guide to Computer Programming Languages - SXSW · Vulk Coop · 1:02:35
- Bret Victor Inventing on Principle · Luna Programming Language Tutorials · 54:20
- Douglas Adams - Hyperland · UJ ObscureMedia · 49:22
- Head Tracking for Desktop VR Displays using the WiiRemote · Johnny Lee · 4:46
- RSA ANIMATE: Drive: The surprising truth about what motivates us · Royal Society of Arts · 10:48
- Hammock Driven Development - Rich Hickey · ClojureTV · 39:49