36C3 - Open Source is Insufficient to Solve Trust Problems in Hardware

Channel:media.ccc.de · Length:1:00:45 · Published:2019-12-27 · Views:12677

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A 36C3 talk by Bunnie Huang arguing that open source is necessary but not sufficient for trustworthy hardware, because verifying hardware is destructive and so creates a time-of-check/time-of-use gap. It surveys supply chain security and classes of hardware attacks, and presents the Betrusted approach to narrowing that gap.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters point to it whenever the question is how far hardware can be trusted, including FPGAs, supply chain attacks and firmware TPMs.

Here's an excellent talk that addresses your question — HN, 2020

Security & hacking · Semiconductors & chip manufacturing · Hacker culture & free software

Subtitles (excerpt)

[Music] welcome everybody our very first talk on the first day of Congress the talk is open source is insufficient to solve trust problems and hardware and although there is a lot to be said for free and open software it is unfortunately not always inherently more secure than proprietary or closed software and the same goes for hardware as well and this talk will take us into the nitty-gritty bits of how to build trust able hardware and how it has to be implemented and brought together with the software in order to be secure we have one speaker here today it's Bonnie he's a hardware and firmware hacker but actually the talk was worked on by three people so it's not just Bonnie but also Sean jobs cross and Tom marble but the other two are not present today but I would like you to welcome our speaker bunny with a big warm round of applause and have a lot of fun good morning everybody thanks for braving the crowds and making it into the Congress and thank you again to the Congress for giving me the privilege to address the Congress again this year very very exciting being the first talk of the day I had font problems I'm running from a PDF backup so we'll see how this all goes good thing I make backups so topic of today's talk is open source is insufficient to solve

On Hacker News

Here's an excellent talk that addresses your question: Open Source is Insufficient to Solve Trust Problems in Hardware [1]. [1] [VIDEO] — Confiks, 2020-11
Here's an excellent talk that addresses your question: Open Source is Insufficient to Solve Trust Problems in Hardware [1]. [1] [VIDEO] — Confiks, 2020-05
As I'm sure you're aware FPGAs are nice because they can complicate things for an attacker in the physical supply chain. Andrew "bunnie" Huang did an excellent talk on the subject: [VIDEO] — kfreds, 2023-05
There’s really no way to ever be 100% sure of hardware. Sure we could use FPGAs for all hardware and then the hardware “source” is software, but who makes the FPGAs? There’s techniques even under X-ray to mask a rogue chip. [VIDEO] — skinner927, 2021-11

Related videos