Superluminal Time Travel + Time Warp Challenge Answer

Channel:PBS Space Time · Length:11:48 · Published:2017-03-22 · Views:1018828

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A PBS Space Time episode explaining why faster-than-light travel is equivalent to travelling back in time, using relativity and Minkowski diagrams for different observers.

Why HN recommends it

HN points to it in warp drive discussions as a math-free explanation of why superluminal travel causes causality problems.

One video with no maths required. — HN, 2022

Fundamental physics · Cosmology & astrophysics

Subtitles (excerpt)

Traveling faster than light and traveling backwards in time are the same thing. Today I'm going to prove that to you. Faster-than-light travel is, understandably, a staple of science fiction. The reality of the vast scale of our universe, even with our galaxy, is inconvenient for tales of star-hopping adventure or warring galactic empires. Enter the warp drive, and hyperspace, and star gates, and the infinite improbability drive. Plenty of ways to make traveling across impossible distances as challenging as a weekend road trip. And sci-fi makes instantaneous communication a breeze. We have ansibles, sophons, subspace relays, and tachyonic antitelephones. Actually, that last one is a thought experiment that demonstrates that if you communicate using tachyons, hypothetical faster-than-light or superluminal particles, it's possible to receive and reply to a message before the message is sent. By choosing the right path and the right reference frame, any superluminal motion can lead to information or objects returning to their origin before they depart. Today I want to show you how to navigate such a path. To do that, we're going to need a map. We'll do this in flat space, so we need a flat or Minkowski spacetime diagram.

On Hacker News

One video with no maths required. [VIDEO] Without the math you can't get a deep understanding or reason about it too much but you can see the issue. — xupybd, 2022-07
Here's a good (IMHO) video showing how this works out, by looking Minkowski diagrams for different observers. [VIDEO] — magicalhippo, 2018-08
There's an episode of PBS Space Time about this, "The Speed of Light is NOT About Light" [1], which comes pretty close to making the same points you are making. It might be useful to watch this earlier episode, "Are Space and Time an Illusion?" [2], first. There is a later episode (or maybe a couple of them) that go into how interactions with the Higgs field make it so things with mass travel slo… — tzs, 2020-11

Related videos