Idaho Stop for Cyclists? Drivers Already Do It!

Channel:Oh The Urbanity! · Length:4:22 · Published:2021-07-25 · Views:33651

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A short urbanism video presenting original observations of how drivers treat stop signs, to argue that cyclists rolling through them under an Idaho stop is no different. It filmed intersections in Ottawa.

Why HN recommends it

Linked in threads on the Idaho and Colorado safety stop as evidence that drivers already roll stop signs.

Oh the Urbanity! Recently had a great episode on this as well — HN, 2022

Transit, cities & urban planning

Subtitles (excerpt)

If you pay attention to debates about urban cycling and bike infrastructure you’ve probably seen that there’s a certain stereotype of cyclists as renegade rule-breakers who think they’re above the law. One of the most common criticisms that you see is about cyclists not coming to a complete stop at stop signs because, of course, the sign says stop, so you’re supposed to stop. Obviously we’re not going to try to convince you that cyclists always stop at stop signs. That’s clearly not true. The thing that people seem to be forgetting though is that this isn’t something specific to cyclists, this is normal road behaviour. Drivers don’t usually come to a complete stop at stop signs either, unless there’s someone in the intersection forcing them too. At least, that’s always been our experience. To test this intuition, we went to three intersections in Ottawa and counted how many cars come to a complete stop at the stop signs over a 20 minute period. The results were... pretty much what we expected. Of the 233 total cars that we counted, 55 came to a complete stop while 178 rolled on through, sometimes faster and sometimes slower, but all without actually stopping as indicated on the stop sign.

On Hacker News

I'll also add that the anger of motorists towards cyclists rolling through stop signs is completely irrational when you take into consideration that approximately 100% of motorists also run through almost all stop signs, so long as they aren't blocked by an other car. This twitter video exemplifies it pretty well [LINK] We just take for granted that cars will blast through stop signs at a pretty … — joshlemer, 2022-11
It's not as comprehensive as you're probably looking for, but I saw a video a while back with some observations on this in Ottawa: [VIDEO] — ryukafalz, 2023-06
This is actually what this law is about. The difference between a cyclist at a stop sign and your average vehicle is visibility. Cyclists don't have blind spots the way cars & trucks do. So if you can reasonably see that there is no immediate traffic, you don't have to wait at an intersection and risk hoping that another driver at a 4 way stop will respect the stop sign. This whole law is being c… — ThatGeoGuy, 2022-04

Related videos