Elon Musk on Cameras vs LiDAR for Self Driving and Autonomous Cars

Channel:AutoPilot Review · Length:10:24 · Published:2019-04-27 · Views:226938

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A clip from Tesla Autonomy Day 2019 where Elon Musk argues cameras are enough for self-driving and calls lidar a fool's errand.

Why HN recommends it

Cited in self-driving threads as the source of Tesla's vision-only stance, usually to discuss or push back on it.

I think Elon Musk makes some good points why Lidar — HN, 2020

Self-driving & autonomous vehicles · Cars, EVs & motorcycles

Subtitles (excerpt)

LAR is is a fool's errand and any and anyone relying on LAR is doomed. Expensive sensors that are are unnecessary. It's like having a whole bunch of expensive appendic appendices like one appendix is bad. Well, now I want to put a whole bunch of them. That's ridiculous. So in the next section of my talk, I'm going to especially talk about depth perception using vision only. So you might be familiar that there are uh at least two sensors uh in a car. One is vision cameras just getting pixels and the other is LAR that a lot of uh a lot of companies also use. And LAR gives you these point measurements of distance around you. Um, now one one thing I'd like to point out first of all is you all came here, you drove here, many of you, and you used your your neural net and vision. You were not shooting lasers out of your eyes and you still ended up here. We might have things went well. That's good for everyone. So clearly the human neural net deres distance and all the measurements and the 3D understanding of the world just from vision. It actually uses multiple cues to do so. I'll just briefly go over some of them just to give you a sense of roughly what's going on in inside. Um, as an example, we have two eyes pointed out.

On Hacker News

I think Elon Musk makes some good points why Lidar isn’t the best choice. [VIDEO] Waymo taxi looks incredible but how can they scale it. — Ecstatify, 2020-10
Anyone who owns a Tesla and has used the new V12.3 understands why Elon is so bullish about the Robo-Taxi's. He's said they've internally seen a 5x-10x reduction in disengagements on 12.4 (already trained, out soon), and that 12.5 is even better. Their GPU stack by end of the year will also be 8x the size it was earlier this year. Combine all this together, and the "feedback loop" with millions o… — EcommerceFlow, 2024-05
Its an interesting video but its an edited video. The company website mentions the system was able to negotiate the challenges of the driving conditions, looks like an euphemism... Very few details, no scientific publications I could find on their Asimov system on a quick search, not sure if this is a technological breakthrough or a fine tuning of existing processes and methods. Because if its a … — belter, 2021-07
Elon talked about LIDAR at the autonomy investor day. Basically he said that the Dragon spacecraft has LIDAR and he spearheaded that effort. He also said that LIDAR and cameras both use the same wavelength, if you are going to add a sensor it makes more sense to add one which is outside of the visible wavelength. Even though I know nothing about driverless cars, the reasoning from Elon makes sens… — neillyons, 2021-01

Related videos