Does the Past Still Exist?

Channel:Sabine Hossenfelder · Length:16:06 · Published:2022-07-23 · Views:7554158

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Sabine Hossenfelder explains how special relativity leads to the block universe, in which past, present and future all exist equally, and asks what that means for whether the past still exists.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters share it as a clear explanation of the block universe and relativity of simultaneity.

This video by Sabine Hossenfelder explains it nicely — HN, 2023

Fundamental physics · Philosophy & ethics

Subtitles (excerpt)

One of the biggest mysteries of our existence is also one of the biggest mysteries of physics: time. We experience time as passing, with a special moment that we call “now”. Now you’re watching this video, half an hour ago you were doing something else. Whatever you did, there’s no way to change it. And what you will do in half an hour is up to you. At least that’s how we perceive time. But what physics tells us about time is very different from our perception. The person who figured this out was none other than Albert Einstein. I know. That guy again. Turns out he kind of knew it all. What did Einstein teach us about the past, the present, and the future? That’s what we’ll talk about today. The topic we’re talking about today is covered in more detail in my new book “existential physics” which will be published in August. You find more info about the book at existentialphysics dot com We think about time as something that works the same for everyone and every object. If one second passes for me, one second passes for you, and one second passes for the clouds above. This makes time a universal parameter. This parameter labels how much time passes and also what we all mean by “now”. Hermann Minkowski was the first to notice that

On Hacker News

I haven’t heard anyone express this before, but when it comes to my death and the deaths of others, I take comfort in the idea of the Block Universe. On the Block Universe concept, time isn’t real in the way we think about it—everything that ever happened or will happen exists in a timeless, eternal block of spacetime. (This video by Sabine Hossenfelder explains it nicely: [VIDEO] .) If this is t… — glennonymous, 2023-07
To be fair there is some disagreement over what exactly "the past" _is_. [VIDEO] discusses this a bit. — CalRobert, 2023-03
I feel like I must be missing something but in the part about the relativity of simultaneity [0] I feel like this is more about the relativity of the observers and the limitations of speed of light than it is about the ontology of time itself? The definition of "now" as when the light hits the mirror on each side is a "constructed" now, a false now if you may. It takes the light longer on the rig… — ffwd, 2022-07

Related videos