The LED Traffic Light and the Danger of "But Sometimes!"

Channel:Technology Connections · Length:18:31 · Published:2018-05-14 · Views:4221372

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Technology Connections explains how LED traffic lights, which do not melt snow, drew complaints and were blamed for accidents. He uses it to illustrate the 'but sometimes' fallacy against new technology.

Why HN recommends it

Cited constantly as the name and example of the 'but sometimes' argument, where edge cases are used to resist better technology such as EVs and solar.

I love Technology Connections' take on this line of argument [0] — HN, 2024

Transit, cities & urban planning · Futurism & technology and society · Scientific method & science communication

Subtitles (excerpt)

Well you seemed to like the jacket, so… I’ll keep it. I have a bit of a fascination with stop lights (or traffic lights, if you prefer). They boil down to remarkably simple devices, little more than indicators, but thanks to driver’s education and the magic of the human brain, they are remarkably effective at safely controlling traffic at intersections. Well, most of the time. Now, there’s so much to get into regarding traffic lights. Traffic engineering is a fascinating subject which I don’t feel qualified to discuss, but there’s quite the rabbit hole to fall into. This video is about a simple but groundbreaking innovation in the traffic light and the lessons it can tell us about innovation in general. This is about the LED traffic light, and the caution of “but sometimes”. I live in an area of my town that’s not terribly well traveled. Though there are many 4 lane roads with speed limits of 35 to 40 miles an hour, the traffic volume honestly doesn’t often justify having two lanes in each direction. Many of the stop lights in this area have been neglected, and are still using good-’ol fashioned incandescent bulbs with colored glass lenses. Actually, some are so old that they still have the written text “WALK’ and “DON’T

On Hacker News

I love Technology Connections' take on this line of argument [0]: > When there's a new innovation which changes how we do things for the better, its benefits are obvious. ... However when the "But Sometimes" rears its ugly head, people tend to freak out. Suddenly all those benefits go away, because in this one particular facet of stoplight functionality, the wasteful and maintenance-heavy incande… — lolinder, 2024-08
The one on traffic lights is way more interesting than it sounds! Everybody should check it out. There's also a really interesting point he makes at the end that applies to something a lot of people on HN might relate with [VIDEO] The toaster one is alright, it kinda bothered me when he said there was "literally NO reason" to design something the way it was (I think it had to do with the position… — chipperyman573, 2020-02
I watched a YouTube video [0] this morning which actually does a fantastic job of explaining the pros and cons of LED-based traffic lights. Short answer: it's complicated. [0]: [VIDEO] — dlivingston, 2019-05
>Apropos of nothing... I also remember a story about a northern country replacing traffic lights with LEDs and then spending even more money adding heaters because the old lights were naturally warm, and melted any ice that stuck to the lights. Can't find a link to it at the moment. The Technology Connections channel on YouTube has an excellent video on this, called 'The LED Traffic Light and the… — M2Ys4U, 2021-03
You may be interested in the video The LED Traffic Light and the Danger of "But Sometimes!" by Technology Connections: [VIDEO] — someperson, 2021-03

Related videos