This is Why Heat Pumps May NOT Be The Future

Channel:Skill Builder · Length:13:12 · Published:2021-07-19 · Views:2554866

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A UK tradesman's rant on the disadvantages of air source heat pumps, covering grants, heat pump types and whether they are worth it. He argues they are impractical for many British homes.

Why HN recommends it

HN uses it mostly as a contrarian or skeptical reference, with some commenters noting it glosses over details.

Power grid, heating & buildings · Home, DIY & practical skills

Subtitles (excerpt)

[Music] Hello, I'm Roger Bisby from the Skillbuilder channel back with another rant and this time I want to talk to you about a car crash. A car crash that I can see happening in slow motion coming your way. And basically the car crash I'm talking about is heat pumps and specifically the government's idea of incentivizing people to take up the heat pump technology by pouring 11.8 8 billion pounds of your taxpaying money into the pockets of companies who are going to install heat pumps. Now 11.8 billion very easy to say you know we're used to talking about billions and trillions these days and what the government's chucking at this that and the other but don't forget 11.8 8 billion pounds. That's a lot of money and it's only the tip of the iceberg because they vastly underestimated how much money it will cost to put these heat pumps in. The whole idea of incentivizing people to install heat pumps is so that they can get rid of gas boilers. Now, at the moment, when you look at people's fuel bills, running a heat pump is roughly three times more expensive than running a gas boiler. Now, you can argue with that. I know there will be people out there who are saying, "I've installed a heat pump

On Hacker News

I don't know how true this is since I'm no expert, there's a YouTube video explaining why heat pumps may not be so simple a solution at least in the UK [VIDEO] Interestingly the prediction he made, regarding gas prices, did come true. — politelemon, 2022-03
Heat pumps are rather inefficient according to this video [1]. Are you not bothered by all the noise it generates? Why not just use electric heater instead of a heat pump? 1 - [VIDEO] — kblev, 2021-12
Few domestic buildings in the UK have the space to install the huge and noisy air conditioning fan required, never mind the insulated piping to get the heat into the house. It's a nice idea, but the reality is that most people will end up heating their water with a good old immersion heater. See [VIDEO] The real problem is our buildings are badly built and insulated - and the new ones just aren't… — neilwilson, 2021-08
For a video that glosses over the details but loudly proclaims this “ugly truth” there’s this one. I can’t tell if he is a paid shill for the gas industry or just obtuse, or maybe a voice of common sense in the wilderness…. [VIDEO] — hasmanean, 2022-07

Related videos