Antonin Scalia - On American Exceptionalism

Channel:AmericanRhetoric.com · Length:7:21 · Published:2016-02-19 · Views:1019748

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Justice Antonin Scalia's opening statement at a 2011 Senate Judiciary hearing on the role of judges. He argues that the Constitution's separation of powers is what protects liberty, and that gridlock is by design.

Why HN recommends it

Recommended often as a clear explanation of why the US system is built to be slow and why gridlock protects minorities.

one of the best explanations for why founding fathers built the system the way they did is this[1], by late Justice Scalia. — HN, 2022

US politics & elections · Law, policing & justice

Subtitles (excerpt)

thank you Mr chairman members of the committee I'm happy to be back in front of the Judiciary Committee where where I started this uh uh pilgrimage uh I am going to get even more fundamental than uh uh my good friend and colleague like him I I speak uh to students especially law students but also college students and even high school students quite frequently about the Constitution uh because I feel that we're we're not teaching it very well um I I speak to law students from the the best law schools people presumably especially interested in the law and I ask them how many of you have read The Federalist Papers and well a lot of hands will go no not just number 48 and the big ones how many of you have read The Federalist Papers cover to cover never more than about 5% and that is very sad I mean if especially if you're interested in the Constitution here's a document that says what the framers of it thought they were doing it it's such a a profound exposition of political science that it is studied in in political science courses in Europe and yet we we have raised a generation of Americans who are not familiar with it so when when I speak to these groups the first point I I make and I think it's even a

On Hacker News

It depends on where you draw the line for acting in good faith. Justice Antonin Scalia's opening statement before a 2011 Senate Judiciary Committee hearing is worth watching. [VIDEO] Even more worth reading are the Federalist Papers, cover-to-cover, as he suggested. The depth to which the Framers considered the kind of situations we are in today is amazing. — emchammer, 2025-09
I highly recommend watching this video [1] to understand why "progress has stalled". Believe it or not, it's by design. 1. [VIDEO] — splintercell, 2020-06
This is basically the intent of the structure of the US government. High degree of separation of powers (unlike most other democracies, the executive is separate from the legislative and there are two independent legislative bodies). High level of agreement across multiple bodies before a law can be passed (House, Senate and President). I thought Scalia's explanation was a good one: [VIDEO] — refurb, 2024-11
Ron Chernow's biography on him is really excellent. It's so good that I think it's actually a disservice to mention that it inspired the Broadway play. If you can respect Scalia's legal talent, this video where he mentions them is interesting: [VIDEO] — arkis22, 2023-07
The design of the American system was always based on a distrust for power. The gridlock is the point. Not my favorite person but Scalia put it well: [VIDEO] — letmevoteplease, 2023-05

Related videos