The Most Persistent Myth

Channel:Veritasium · Length:7:23 · Published:2014-12-01 · Views:2750998

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Veritasium argues that every new technology, from motion pictures to TV, was predicted to revolutionize education and none did. It asks what actually could, drawing on the host's physics education research.

Why HN recommends it

HN cites it in education and AI threads as a history of failed technology-will-transform-teaching predictions.

for why TV or anything else didn't obsolete teaching — HN, 2024

Education & learning · Futurism & technology and society

Subtitles (excerpt)

This will revolutionize education. No prediction has been made as often or as incorrectly as that one. In 1922, it was Thomas Edison who declared that, “The motion picture is destined to revolutionize our educational system and that in a few years, it will supplant largely, if not entirely, the use of textbooks.” Yeah. And you know how that worked out? By the 1930s it was radio. The idea was you could beam experts directly into classrooms, improving the quality of education for more students at lower cost. And that would mean you require fewer skilled teachers, a theme common to all of the proposed education revolutions, like that of educational television in the 1950s and 60s. Studies were conducted to determine whether students preferred watching a lecture live, or sitting in an adjacent room where the same lecture was broadcast via closed circuit TV. What would you prefer? In the 80s there was no debating. Computers were the revolutionary solution to our education woes. They were audiovisual, interactive, and could be programmed to do almost anything you like. Well at the time, they could run Oregon Trail. But their potential was obvious. Researches suspected that if they could teach

On Hacker News

Of course it has been a problem, I provided you with books from the 60s and the 70s to show a better way to educate people. See [VIDEO] for why TV or anything else didn't obsolete teaching. — chx, 2024-10
Reminds me of "This Will Revolutionize Education: No prediction has been made as often, and as incorrectly as that." [VIDEO] The main problem is that learning is hard, and occurs inside the learner's head, rather than anything external outside of the learner. — Kortaggio, 2020-10
We definitely have had a long history of "this changes everything for education!"[1], but 15 years is a long time for internet infrastructure to change and spread. The article seems to allude to such innovations. [1] [VIDEO] — Hytosys, 2015-01

Related videos