Leading Questions - Yes Prime Minister

Channel:LimeXd · Length:2:17 · Published:2012-01-15 · Views:1596600

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A clip from Yes Prime Minister in which Sir Humphrey shows how leading questions can make a survey support or oppose national service. It is a short satirical scene.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters bring it up whenever a poll or survey result looks suspect, as the classic illustration of biased question framing.

An excellent illustration of this — HN, 2020

Data science & statistics · Satire & parody · Film & TV clips

Subtitles (excerpt)

he's going to say something new and radical in the broadcast what that silly Grand Design burnard that was precisely what you had to avoid how did this come about I shall need a very good explanation well he's very keen on it what's that got to do with it things don't happen just because Prime Ministers are very keen on them Neville Chamberlain was very keen on peace he thinks he thinks it's a vote winner Ah that's more serious don't what makes him think that well the party who had an opinion poll done it seems all the voters are in favor of bringing back national service well I have another opinion poll done showing the voters are against bringing back national service we can't be for of course they can burnard have you ever been surveyed yes well not me actually my house oh I see what you B you know what happens nice young lady comes up to you obviously you want to create a good impression you don't want to look a fool do you no no so she starts asking you some questions Mr Willie are you worried about the number of young people without jobs yes are you worried about the rise in crime among teenagers yes do you think there's a lack of discipline in our comprehensive schools yes do you think young

On Hacker News

Polls may or may not be carried out in a neutral way. A good many are deliberately biased, even more have known flaws that are glossed over. A humorous take on this I love (from the 80s BBC comedy Yes Minister, which is often scarily realistic): [VIDEO] — graemep, 2024-11
This is probably a good time to recall that polling in politics can be highly misleading . I recall an excellent segment on Yes, Minister that explains it [0, 1]. We really need to know the other questions they were being asked at the time to see if they were primed in some way. A near majority being uncomfortable with white people would be outrageous, but Americans are usually pretty tolerant so… — roenxi, 2023-02
Link for the curious: [VIDEO] Starts at about 1:00. One of my favorite shows Edit: updated link, thanks @dvngnt_ — Jalad, 2022-03
> the questions can shape the response. An excellent illustration of this: [VIDEO] Although in this case, it doesn't look like they had bad intentions and they seem to have dug at least a little below the surface and drawn what seem like sensible conclusions. I wonder if more detailed results and the full list of questions are available somewhere. — waterhouse, 2020-08
You are probably talking about the YouGov poll. The poll asked a clearly leading question IMO. You can get any result you want by asking leading questions on polling. This was of course satirised by Yes Minister. [VIDEO] I can counter any of the iffy polls by simple point to the official online petitions service. There were a huge number of signatures to revoke OSA and two million signatures to a… — agedclock, 2025-09

Related videos