Collapse of Complex Societies by Dr. Joseph Tainter

Channel:vlada888 · Length:1:33:25 · Published:2012-08-06 · Views:207721

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Joseph Tainter lectures at a 2010 sustainability conference on why complex societies such as Rome collapse. His thesis is that rising complexity brings diminishing returns until societies cannot afford to maintain it.

Why HN recommends it

Recommended as the best exposition of Tainter's theory, and used to explain slowing innovation, centralization and collapse risk.

Spend some time watching Tainter's speech on complexity and collapse — HN, 2020

World history · Social issues & culture · Futurism & technology and society

Subtitles (excerpt)

thank you Aaron thank you for the invitation to be here and for the introduction it is a great pleasure to be here as Aaron mentioned I did my graduate work just um over the lake here in Evon Illinois and I'm a little surprised to see how mild it is um for Mid November in the early Midwest it's I can tell you it's milder here than it is in Northern Utah um collapse is a term that has many colloquial meanings um and it's often used carelessly without being defined it's also a term that has come to have a number of um it's become a popular Topic in the last uh few years the uh two magazines here are a couple of Science News magazines that both featured collapse as their cover stories these both came out I believe in 2008 or or thereabouts and this was becoming uh an interest even before the financial collapse so I think it reflects a concern a worry um that people are concerned about the future and and we find that reflected in the popular press with people writing about it uh my own conception of a collapse and and I think I need to make this explicit since it is a popularly used term is that a collapse is the rapid simplification of a society um and the paradigmatic case of course would be uh the dark ages of Europe

On Hacker News

The best way to think about this is the classic Buckminster Fuller quote "You never change things by fighting the existing reality. To change something, build a new model that makes the existing model obsolete." Spend some time watching Tainter's speech on complexity and collapse: [VIDEO] . Particularly the adult conversations we need to have at the end of the talk. Also try Kate Raworth's explan… — seltzered_, 2020-05
> Burn it all down and start over We won't be the ones doing that. > We're going to have to figure this sustainability thing out though It may be already late. I wish it wasn't so. I think we could have chance at repairing it ... if only we would do what's necessary. But we're not doing what's necessary, we never started even discussing it, and I'm starting to doubt that we'll ever do. We're talk… — myshpa, 2023-07
The author's position seems to be that the very notion of civilizational collapse is flawed because people often come up with reductionist, poorly supported ways of explaining it. The unspoken implication here is that whoever brings up a threat of collapse in a political argument hasn't got a clue what he's talking about. Stephen Bannon referencing Gibbons work comes to mind, and, come think of i… — monday_, 2017-11
This video [1] has a great explanation and exploration of why innovation seems to be slowing down. He uses data coming from the patent system over a period of 100 years. The video touches on much of what is in this study and does a great job of explaining it. [1] [VIDEO] — jontas, 2016-12
This is incorrect, societies have collapsed regularly throughout history. A collapse doesn't have to be a total destruction of the society, it's most often a fast transition to a lower level of social complexity. One of my favorite books (and a book referenced by the link above) is "The Collapse of Complex Societies" by Joseph A Tainter, he gives a great study on the nature of collapse with lots … — faizshah, 2015-04

Related videos