Alan Kay - Normal Considered Harmful

Channel:powerfuloutlet · Length:1:07:26 · Published:2012-03-25 · Views:60018

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Alan Kay's 2009 UIUC talk arguing that computing is more a pop culture than a science and that ignoring history and fundamentals leads to inferior solutions. He touches on the history of interactive environments and what the web should have been.

Why HN recommends it

A staple on must-watch lists, recommended as a starting point for Kay's thinking and for why software is often poor and ahistorical.

his talk 'Normal Considered Harmful' in particular is worth a look as it pretty much goes straight to the heart of the issue — HN, 2023

Software architecture & design · History of computing · Tech pioneers & interviews

Subtitles (excerpt)

this is a kind of a fortress setup of kind of the professor against the students uh but the cable is short so I have to duck back there periodically um thank you all for coming out I believe I am the second prize in the raffle um this this talk is uh is about some of the ways I think about our field it's not particularly technical it asks a lot of questions it's an attempt to be critical without being a rant and uh it won't be successful unless I can get you to interact uh periodically there'll be a couple of opportunities uh early in the talk and the title of the talk uh deals with two properties of frogs one of them is that their nervous systems like all nervous systems are mainly interested in differences but unlike us they are able to habituate very rapidly and so it is amazingly true that if you put a frog in a pot of water and heat it up very slowly slowly they will not get out because the the differences that their nervous system are detecting are too small over the unit of time that their nervous systems work on and uh they will just stay there until they cook and of course we aren't like that and the other interesting property of flies which I think is one of the most amazing property and it was first uh discovered in a landmark paper called

On Hacker News

Richard Feynman is the best teacher we know (explaining electricity): [LINK] He also explains seeing, heat, electro magnetism, elasticity and mirrors among other things. His academic lectures are just as good but too long and hard for laymen to follow. - Every time I switch on an electrical device I hear Feynman say 'Zzzzinggg' and I see the copper bars jiggling across town. - Every time I see a … — morphle, 2022-09
"The Mess We're In" by Joe Armstrong: [LINK] "Normal Considered Harmful" by Alan Kay: [VIDEO] — bluetomcat, 2017-02
You can't fix a broken wheel. This web link post, the original NEXT webbrowser, tries to celebrate and revive the reinvention of the broken wheel. The World Wide Web, browser and html standards are a very broken wheel. Alan Kay, the inventor of personal computing, explains why: [VIDEO] Some of the comments of youtube are fun too. This lecture Alan aimed at this particular audience, the computer s… — morphle, 2026-02
If you're okay with a System 6 appearance, I've already made one < [LINK] >, for Advanced Mac Substitute < [LINK] >. I do appreciate Alan Kay's thinking, in particular his talk "Normal Considered Harmful" < [VIDEO] > My own high-level language, Varyx, has somewhat LISPy internals and is very dynamic — for example, you can annotate a variable with a type that's determined only at run time — and ha… — jjuran, 2025-11
Alan Kay has done a few lectures about exactly this phenomenon: his talk 'Normal Considered Harmful' in particular is worth a look as it pretty much goes straight to the heart of the issue: [VIDEO] — logicalshift, 2023-02

Related videos