Exact Instructions Challenge PB&J Classroom Friendly | Josh Darnit

Channel:Josh Darnit · Length:6:44 · Published:2017-04-20 · Views:1603274

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A family comedy video in which kids write instructions for making a peanut butter and jelly sandwich, and a parent follows them with exact literalness, producing chaos. This is the classroom-friendly version.

Why HN recommends it

HN uses it as shorthand for how hard it is to write unambiguous instructions, in discussions of programming, tutorials and LLM prompting.

a famous YouTube video[0] about how to write instructions that can be followed — HN, 2026

Software (other) · Stand-up & sketch comedy · Education & learning

Subtitles (excerpt)

- You're not even making any sense. You already ruined it on purpose. He knows how to make one. - What's up The Internet? You know what? I'm hungry. I could really go for a peanut butter and jelly sandwich. Do you guys think you could write down some instructions and teach me how to make a peanut butter and jelly sandwich? - Yeah. - Then do it. - I knew we were gonna do this. I heard dad talking to mom. - Choke yourself on my hand. Sometimes they do what you tell them. (laughter) - [Evan] Dad, I'm done. - Step one, get two pieces of bread out. Got 'em. Get a butter knife and get some PB. Take one piece of bread, spread it around with the butter knife. - No, dad. With the peanut butter. - I'm just doing what it says. It says, take one piece of bread, spread it around with the butter knife. - Hold on. - Get some jelly, rub it on the other half of the bread. - No, dad open the jelly. - It doesn't say to do that. Put the breads together, on top of each other. Take a big bite. (giggles) - This doesn't taste like a peanut butter and jelly sandwich. (giggles) (loud buzzer) - Yeah, yeah. Oh yeah. - Sorry, I had to make it extremely specific. - Oh good, I'm starving. - Take two pieces of white bread out of the bag.

On Hacker News

It’s a reference to a famous YouTube video[0] about how to write instructions that can be followed. One of the most important things a programmer needs to do is learn how to tell a computer how to do something. It’s a surprisingly hard skill because each step is way more complicated and has way more variables to go through. [VIDEO] — t-writescode, 2026-03
> why do you not program in assembly? There's a balance of levels of abstraction. Abstraction is a great thing. Abstraction can make your programs faster, more flexible, and more easy to understand. But abstraction can also make your programs slower, more brittle, and incomprehensible. The point of code is to write specification. That is what code is. The whole reason we use a pedantic and somewh… — godelski, 2026-02
No. Natural language is vague, ambiguous and indirect. Watch these poor children struggle with writing instructions for making a sandwich: [VIDEO] — geon, 2026-02
I don't think you're wrong but I think you're being too quick to attack the gp. They're not wrong either. The point you brought up doesn't contradict theirs but adds nuance. I'm all for nuance. Its also why I'm biased towards long form media as it's more likely to contain nuance, but not guaranteed. The gps specific example of lectures is quite narrow and more likely to have depth. Which is the e… — godelski, 2025-11
Do you know certain shoes are banned in running competitions? There's a really fine line here. We make shoes to help us run faster and keep our feet safe, right? Those two are directly related, as we can't run very fast if our feet are injured. But how far can this be taken? You can make shoes that dramatically reduce the impact when the foot strikes the ground, which reduces stress on the foot a… — godelski, 2025-10

Related videos