Is Meat Really that Bad?

Channel:Kurzgesagt – In a Nutshell · Length:10:13 · Published:2021-11-30 · Views:9262888

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A Kurzgesagt animated explainer on the climate and environmental cost of meat. It covers how beef drives deforestation and emissions, and how this compares with plant-based foods.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters cite it as a clear, well-sourced summary of why meat, especially beef, has such a large environmental footprint.

Kurzgesagt just did a great video on the subject — HN, 2021

Nutrition & diet science · Climate science & climate change · Environment, agriculture & food systems

Subtitles (excerpt)

Food is arguably the best thing about being alive. No other bodily pleasure is enjoyed multiple times every day and never gets old. It is an expression of culture, our parents' love and a means of celebration or comfort. That’s why it hits a special nerve when we are told we should change what and how we eat to fight rapid climate change. One of the most delicious foods, meat gets the worst press. It doesn’t help that the topic is really hard to properly research yourself and debates get emotional quickly. But clearly science can give us an answer! The reality is, well, it’s complicated. Let’s take a look at three climate arguments against meat that are used a lot and see what happens. # 1. Does our Diet REALLY play that big a role in climate change? Feeding billions of people is impossible without causing emissions. Even if someday we have zero-carbon tractors, refrigerators and cookers running on renewable energy and electric trucks to move our food, there are still unavoidable emissions. Rice emits methane. We cut down forests to make room for pastures and crops. And we emit nitrous oxide when we use fertilizers and manure. Worldwide food production is responsible for about 26% of all human-made greenhouse gas emissions.

On Hacker News

How do you arrive at the conclusion that the best thing to do in the US is switch your meats? Every form from animal protein is going to be less efficient than plant protein and result in more emissions [1]. There are some amazing Kurzgesagt videos exposing how and why that is true [2]. So since we know that eating animals is not required to be healthy at any stage of life [3] (assuming basic acc… — sweetheart, 2022-08
Here's a related recent video from Kurzgesagt, discussing how space for beef cattle drives deforestation in Brazil. [VIDEO] — karmelapple, 2021-12
Lots of disinformation here. Let's start from the top: 1. Veganism isn't a diet, it's a moral belief system. Diet is merely one manifestation of that belief system. 2. "Proteinless garbage"? What is this, the 90s? We've moved beyond the silly misconceptions that protein = meat. Do your research, please. Hitting daily protein goals is absolutely trivial on a vegan diet. Seriously, it's stupidly ea… — sweetheart, 2021-12
There is a Kurzgesagt video on that exact point. Their analysis is that the emissions from shipping plants from further away to make your tofu is a drop in the bucket compared to the emissions you won’t be generating anymore by not consuming meat anymore. Meat which has to also have their food plants shipped around to them, on top of everything else. See [VIDEO] — ornornor, 2022-08
What is health and planet positive based on? Compare the best meat against the worst plant based food and its still plant based>meat: [VIDEO] — tcfhgj, 2022-08

Related videos