America Keeps Rejecting an ID Card It Already Has

Channel:CGP Grey · Length:7:15 · Published:2017-03-29 · Views:13616219

Watch on YouTube

Summary

CGP Grey explains the history of the US Social Security card and number, and why they became a de facto national ID despite never being meant for it. He also covers why America resists a proper identity card.

Why HN recommends it

HN reaches for it in every identity theft and data breach thread as the clearest, most enjoyable short explainer of why SSNs make bad identifiers.

this is the most enjoyable explanation for it I've seen, by CGP Grey — HN, 2017

Privacy, surveillance & cybercrime · Social issues & culture · Politics & history (other)

Subtitles (excerpt)

Americans love their independence... a nation of pioneers living out from under the eye of government ... (except for all the government). As such, unlike many other countries, Americans don't have a national ID card... ...and even the idea of creating one is a political hot topic every election cycle. The results are always the same: we don't need no ID card. But suspiciously, US citizens do already have this: a card with a unique number that many places will ask for to prove who you are. This is the Social Security card and number... ...and it has become a quasi ID / unique password to identify citizens... ...though that was never its intended use. For Americans, keeping this number secret is super important... because it's the key to the government and banks to identifying you as you... … and losing control of it is the worst kind of identity theft that can happen. So how did Americans end up with a national ID number… … that isn't one and a card terribly unfit to identify? It all started in the great depression of long long ago… … when the government created the social security program, … … a kind of mandatory pension: Citizens would be required to pay in during… … their working lives and withdraw in their retirement.

On Hacker News

For anyone who wants an explanation at just how bad the social security number really is, this is the most enjoyable explanation for it I've seen, by CGP Grey [VIDEO] — bmelton, 2017-09
For everybody who isn't acquainted with how Social Security Cards work in the US and how they came to be I highly recommend watching "Social Security Cards Explained" by CGP Grey [VIDEO] He also explains why US citizens don't have an Identity Card as opposed to many European countries. — sagitariusrex, 2017-09
For non-Americans (and Americans) that don't quite understand what SSN is and why it's a problem, CGP Grey [1] has a great (and short) video about the history and why it's not technically an identifier, but has become one. [1] [VIDEO] — quantumfissure, 2024-08
There's an interesting story about how the social security number evolved to being much more than just for social security. Quick 5 minute primer: [VIDEO] — SonicScrub, 2023-11
I'm late to the party, but CGP Grey has an excellent video detailing the flaws of how SSNs are utilized. [VIDEO] — kalverra, 2023-11

Related videos