Notation Must Die: The Battle For How We Read Music

Channel:Tantacrul · Length:1:16:21 · Published:2023-11-03 · Views:1822282

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Tantacrul's 76-minute deep dive into the history of western music notation and the many proposed replacements, such as piano rolls, colored notes and the jubilate. He explains why none have displaced the current system.

Why HN recommends it

Repeatedly recommended as the definitive, well-made explanation of why attempts to reinvent music notation fail and what tradeoffs the current system makes.

excellent deep-ish dive into music notation by the inimitable Tantacrul — HN, 2024

UX & UI design · Music theory, synthesis & production

Subtitles (excerpt)

In Rome, in the year 1590, the Italian priest, Lorenzo Busnardo, a well known chess master, faced off against an opponent whose name is now lost to time. Now, not only is this game a lot of fun, it’s also one of the earliest chess games ever recorded using modern rules and therefore, a fantastic factual document. Let me take a few seconds to show you why this game is so great. Busnardo, playing white, opens with king pawn to E4. Black responds king pawn to E5. White develops the knight to F3. Black plays knight to C6. White then plays bishop C4. A sequence we now call the Italian game, which is the fastest way to open up these two squares, which allows the King to castle safely on the right-hand side of the board. Black responds with bishop C5 Next follows C3, which blocks the knight from moving to B4 while also preparing for a pawn attack on D4. And now for the first notable move of the game, queen to E7. It seems Black is thinking too much about the battle that’s going to take place in the centre of the board and not enough on getting the king safely castled. A better move would have been Pawn to D6 (which allows for the development of the bishop) or Knight F6. For his part, Busnardo now castles, keeping his king safely tucked away here.

On Hacker News

[VIDEO] "Notation Must Die" ... excellent deep-ish dive into music notation by the inimitable Tantacrul — PaulDavisThe1st, 2024-02
If you want an excellent explanation of why proposals for new notation systems like you’re suggesting have been developed (and failed) Tantacrul has made an excellent video describing the history and tradeoffs that lead us to our current system: [VIDEO] He’s product lead at MuseGroup developing notation software and his expertise lies at the intersection of music composition, UX design, and progr… — Slow_Hand, 2026-06
Pro jazz trombonist here. All there is to usefully say about piano roll notation, with or without colours has pretty much already been said. And if you want more (much more) detail, then Tantacrul (designer on MuseScore) has done a great video. [VIDEO] The only useful head's up I can give is the current position marker on your playback is quite a long way behind the audio, around 1-2 beats on the… — midenginedcoupe, 2025-11
Obligatory (long-form) watch if you're going to continue wondering about this: [VIDEO] "Notation must die" by Tantacrul — PaulDavisThe1st, 2024-07
Super cool, great job. Looks like a really fun project. This really highlights why sheet notation is so much better at describing music than tablature. The advantage of tabs is that they tell you which version of the same note to play (You can play the same note in up to 6 places in the guitar). However, sheet notation tells you precisely the duration of each note, and can often include the inten… — javier123454321, 2024-07

Related videos