These Are Not Pixels: Revisited

Channel:Technology Connections · Length:17:04 · Published:2018-04-22 · Views:612037

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Technology Connections follows up on his analog TV video to clear up the debate over whether CRT phosphor dots are pixels. He explains the shadow mask, color triads and how they relate to the scanned picture.

Why HN recommends it

HN links it whenever someone equates CRT phosphors with pixels, as the clear explanation of why they are not.

Definitely worth the watch. — HN, 2023

Audio & video engineering

Subtitles (excerpt)

In this video, I’d like to revisit a concept from my television series. I created this thumbnail for my video explaining analog color TV, and it’s been causing debate ever since. Though I had hoped my video on Trinitron would help illustrate my point and put the debate to rest, there was and is still much debate in the comments. It seems this debate comes mostly from semantics, and I’ll admit I see a gap in my explanation. So let’s try again. This is the TV in my kitchen. Like any TV on sale today, it produces an image by manipulating the brightness of many thousands (and these days millions) of individual picture elements called pixels, which is actually just short for picture element. There are a few different technologies in use these days, but at their core their job is to produce a set brightness value for the red, green, and blue components of each pixel. These are called subpixels, and in many LCD panels each subpixel is actually further divided into sub-sub pixels. This probably increases the total number of discrete brightnesses each color can make, and thus allows for more precise control over the panel and a larger number of possible colors. Someone please correct me if that’s not what the subdivisions do.

On Hacker News

Obligatory Technology Connections video explaining how CRT pixels aren't really pixels as we understand them. Definitely worth the watch. [VIDEO] — ChuckNorris89, 2023-03
If you’re wondering what it’s talking about when it says the triads of red/green/blue rectangles on a CRT display don’t correspond to pixels, here’s a Technology Connections video that explains it: [VIDEO] But on an LCD, the display really is made up of a bunch of solid-colored rectangle-ish shapes, and if the LCD is using standard RGB pattern, each red/green/blue triplet does correspond to one p… — comex, 2023-03
The electron gun draws through the shadow mask, which is fixed and independent of resolution. It's a debate long enjoyed by nitpickers. [LINK] [VIDEO] — morsch, 2020-10
"240p" is not a meaningful statement when referring to CRTs. CRT phosphors are not pixels. For more on that: [VIDEO] — causality0, 2020-06
> The traditional excuse for stripping away ornament has been about improving legibility, especially for small screens. This is a fallacy No, serifs really do have legibility issues, but not for small screens ; they cause problems at (very) small font sizes where glyphs are only a handful of pixels tall. > You can render a serif letter in seven pixels Yes, but that's pushing it and the legibility… — pdkl95, 2018-05

Related videos