A reality check on renewables - David MacKay

Channel:TED-Ed · Length:18:35 · Published:2013-06-26 · Views:986616

Watch on YouTube

Summary

David MacKay's TEDxWarwick talk uses basic arithmetic to show how much land and energy renewables would need to power a country like the UK. It explains the limits of sustainable options and why they should still be pursued.

Why HN recommends it

Cited in energy debates for its back-of-envelope scale of the transition and the land and storage limits of wind and solar.

I found this ted talk on the feasibility of various renewable energy sources quite eye opening — HN, 2019

Climate policy, solutions & debate · Renewables, batteries & storage

Subtitles (excerpt)

[Music] when the Industrial Revolution started the amount of carbon sitting underneath Britain in the form of coal was as big as the amount of carbon sitting under Saudi Arabia in the form of oil and this carbon power the Industrial Revolution it put the great in Great Britain and led to Britain's temporary world domination and then in 198 coal production in Britain peaked and has declined ever since in due course Britain started using oil and gas from the North Sea and in the year 2000 oil and gas production from the North Sea also peaked and then now on the on the decline these observations about the finiteness of easily accessible local secure fossil fuels this is a motivation for saying well what's next what is life after fossil fuels going to be like shouldn't we be thinking hard about how to get off fossil fuels another motivation of course is climate change and when people talk about life after fossil fuels and climate change action I think there's a lot of fluff a lot of greenwash a lot of misleading advertising and I feel a duty as a physicist to try to guide people around the clap trap and help people understand the actions that really make a difference and to focus on ideas that do add up let me

On Hacker News

No energy source [that we've discovered so far] is perfect. All have downsides. Sadly, living in denial of that fact is more popular than ever, but that's a separate topic. Here are a couple TED talks showing the downside of renewable energy - such as the enormous land usage and reliable energy storage needed to compete with nuclear or fossil. Why renewables can’t save the planet [LINK] A reality… — kinjba1, 2020-08
Not everywhere in the world has the land area to do wind and solar. In fact pretty much everywhere other than Russia, Australia, Canada, the US and Brazil. There the energy density per head of population is too high for renewables. Good video by the late David Mackay on that point here. [VIDEO] — neilwilson, 2019-03
On that topic, I found this ted talk on the feasibility of various renewable energy sources quite eye opening [VIDEO] — CuriousSkeptic, 2019-01
Well, a bunch of countries have more or less agreed on aiming for no more than 1.5 degrees warmer. IPCC made a report on what that would entail stating basically that even with an overnight abolishment it cannot be reached. But that if we assume it feasible to use afforestation and other techniques to extract CO2 from the atmosphere in the future we might have chance to reach that target for 2100… — CuriousSkeptic, 2018-12
Briefly: solar and wind energy requires sun or wind and tons of space relative to fossil/nuclear. Not every place has those. "A reality check on renewables" [VIDEO] — kinjba11, 2021-05

Related videos