The Most Misunderstood Concept in Physics

Channel:Veritasium · Length:27:14 · Published:2023-07-01 · Views:31667822

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Veritasium's explainer on entropy, presented as one of physics' most important and least understood concepts. It uses examples such as heat engines and the sun's energy flowing through the Earth.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters say it made entropy intuition click and point to it in threads on energy, heat and equilibrium.

This veritasium video explained it in a way that finally clicked for me — HN, 2024

Fundamental physics

Subtitles (excerpt)

- This is a video about one of the most important, yet least understood concepts in all of physics. It governs everything from molecular collisions to humongous storms. From the beginning of the universe through its entire evolution, to its inevitable end. It may, in fact, determine the direction of time and even be the reason that life exists. To see the confusion around this topic, you need to ask only one simple question. What does the Earth get from the sun? - What does the earth get from sun? - Well, it's light rays? - What do we get from the sun? - Heat. - Warmth. - Warmth, light. - Vitamin D, we get vitamin D from- - We do get vitamin D from the ultraviolet rays. - Well, a lot of energy. - What does the earth get from this, energy? - Yeah, energy. - Energy. - Nailed it. Every day, the earth gets a certain amount of energy from the sun. And then how much energy does the earth radiate back into space relative to that amount that it gets from the sun? - Probably not as much, I, you know, I don't believe it's just radiating right back. - I'd say less. - Less. - Less. - I say less. - I guess about 70%? - It is a fraction. - I'd say 20%. - Because... - Because we use some of it. - We use some of the energy. - Mm-hmm.

On Hacker News

For the longest time I had no real intuition of what entropy actually represented. This veritasium video explained it in a way that finally clicked for me: [VIDEO] — shorefire, 2024-12
I like my entropy story with more steam engines, “The most misunderstood concept in physics", by Veritasium (YouTube, 2023) ( [VIDEO] ) — xtiansimon, 2024-10
This is a great video that touches on your point, the Earth must radiate the heat it receives to stay in equilibrium, even if it uses it to do work in the process. [VIDEO] — theossuary, 2024-02
Maybe watch this video about entropy. Its not about where energy flows, its about hoe entropy can be used to calculate. [VIDEO] — rspoerri, 2023-08
It's not temperature = constant * (energy from sun - energy reflected - energy radiated) Temperature is precisely what leads to 'energy radiated' after all (see: black body emission). Temperature is not 'the leftover energy'. The Earth is broadly in equilibrium. It's more like delta_temperature = constant * (energy from sun - energy reflected - energy radiated) Any imbalance between energy in and… — jameshart, 2023-08

Related videos