Richard Feynman: Magnets and Why Questions

Channel:RichardFeynmanLove · Length:7:41 · Published:2010-10-13 · Views:26301

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A clip from a BBC interview in which Richard Feynman is asked why magnets repel and attract. He explains that "why" questions depend on what a person already accepts as fundamental.

Why HN recommends it

Cited whenever a discussion turns to how hard it is to answer "why" questions or what counts as an explanation.

Feynman, of course, has a pretty definitive response on the difficulty of this problem — HN, 2024

Fundamental physics · Scientific method & science communication

Subtitles (excerpt)

if you get a hold of two magnets and you push them you can feel this pushing between them turn around the other way and and they slam together now what is it the feeling between those two magnets what do you mean what's the feeling between the two magnet something there isn't there I mean that the sensation is that there's something there when you push these two magnets together listen to my question what is the meaning when you say that there's there's a feeling of course you feel it now what do you want to know what I want to know is what's going on between these two bits these two bits of metal mag repel each other and well then what does that but what does that mean or why are they doing that or how are they doing it uh you're ask I must say I think that's a perfectly reasonable question of course it's a reason it's an excellent question okay uh but the problem that you're asking you see when you ask why something happens how does a person answer why something happens for example Aunt Minnie is in a hospital why because she slipped she went out and she slipped on the ice and broke her hip that's satisfies it people it satisfies but it wouldn't satisfy someone who came from another planet knew nothing about things you

On Hacker News

The same is true about the terms "waves" and "fields" when it comes to quantum mechanics. They're analogies. The concepts need names, but I think they do more harm than good because people then start with a mental model of a membrane or a surface - something they have experience seeing waves in. And then after 1 or 2 steps where the analogy helps, it breaks down, and people start being confused. … — deanCommie, 2024-09
> Why is there subjective experience? It evolved in animals because it is advantageous. It is known that even the simplest worms can make a difference between the part of their own body and the body of the other worm or the rest of the environment: they would eat another worm but not their own tail. Worms eating their body are typically not having an advantage (but the local optimums of scarifyin… — acqq, 2019-07
This is not a consensus view by macroeconomists. While fraud may have been important, and possibly more important than macroeconomists believe, I think you do a disservice to the HN reading community by not acknowledging the vast body of experts who have already tried to answer the question of what caused the Great Recession. It's a very difficult question to answer convincingly, given that we ca… — tedsanders, 2015-12

Related videos