The UK's Failed Experiment in Rail Privatization
Channel:Wendover Productions · Length:20:27 · Published:2021-03-09 · Views:2130894
Summary
Wendover Productions explains how UK rail privatization worked and why it failed. It covers the fragmented operator and infrastructure structure and why market forces apply poorly to rail.
Why HN recommends it
Recommended in privatization and rail threads as a clear, well-sourced explanation of the UK rail mess.
the people on the Wendover YouTube channel did a video on this back in March which explained the issue really well. — HN, 2021
Tech industry & business models · Transit, cities & urban planning
Subtitles (excerpt)
This video was made possible by Hover. Set up an email address or website with a custom domain in about two minutes for 10% off at hover.com/wendover. On Thursday, May 3rd, 1979, 31,221,362 voters gathered at polling stations across the United Kingdom to decide on who would fill the 650 seats of the House of Commons. Now, any election is important, but this one held particular significance. Over the years leading up to it, the country’s manufacturing industry was collapsing, inflation was reeking havoc on the economy, mass strikes were plaguing both the public and private sector, unemployment was exploding, and it was quickly becoming clear that Britain was losing ground to Japan, Germany, the US, and other subjects of post-war economic booms. Margaret Thatcher and her Conservative Party proposed a solution: they would curb the power of unions, cut personal income tax, and privatize nationalized industries—essentially, it was a complete rejection of the economic ideology of the prior 30 years. However, in the view of the British public, the status quo was what got them to the turmoil of the era, so Thatcher’s message resonated. Once the ballots were counted, the Conservative Party picked
On Hacker News
> I believe the best way to make this work is by keeping the network itself in public hands and then having a competition of contributors to the network Even then it doesn't always work out - UK rail services have that system - the infrastructure is maintained by a public body [1], but the operators are private. UK rail is quite expensive, and mediocre in quality compared to our EU counterparts. … — sweezyjeezy, 2023-07
I've found that these two YouTube video's do an okay job explaining the actual 'market forces' actually at play here: [LINK] [VIDEO] It takes a bit of understanding why regular market forces kind of can't apply to a system like rail transport. — apexalpha, 2021-05
the people on the Wendover YouTube channel did a video on this back in March which explained the issue really well. [VIDEO] — dangerboysteve, 2021-05
Here's a well-sourced rebuttal to your statement that privatization benefits revenues: [VIDEO] TL;DW revenues and passenger numbers are demonstrably lower with privatization than when nationalized. Unlike other industries, the UK's franchise privatization model is not subjected to free market forces, allowing rail companies to win contracts by underbidding only to fail to meet their targets. — dharmab, 2021-03
It HAS NOT worked great for Sweden. Source: I live in Sweden there was a DN article recently about it. Here it is [LINK] Mirror: [LINK] (Its all too segmented, the trains, the track all different companies now nobody sees the full picture) and [LINK] Mirror: [LINK] (The land is not enough to fix trains and the land next to it was reserved but somehow sold to build a sports arena because the train… — heraldgeezer, 2024-08
Related videos
- Old car headlights were all the same — which was a fairly bright idea · Technology Connections · 25:20
- The Stealership Trap - Why We Need the Dealership "Rip Off" · FortNine · 9:31
- England: South Sea Bubble - The Sharp Mind of John Blunt - Extra History - Part 1 · Extra History · 9:08
- Motorcycle Airbags Exist – But No One Uses Them? · FortNine · 9:36
- Games, Schools, and Worlds Designed for Violence · Jacob Geller · 16:38
- The Problem with Biofuels · Real Engineering · 15:01
- How Facebook is Stealing Billions of Views · Kurzgesagt – In a Nutshell · 5:02
- How Self-Driving Cars will Destroy Cities (and what to do about it) · Not Just Bikes · 54:37
- YouTube's copyright system isn't broken. The world's is. · Tom Scott · 42:29
- Winners Take All | Anand Giridharadas | Talks at Google · Talks at Google · 1:00:56
- Stroads are Ugly, Expensive, and Dangerous (and they're everywhere) [ST05] · Not Just Bikes · 18:13
- Why This Channel Exists (and why I hate Houston) · Not Just Bikes · 17:02
- Why American Cities Are Broke - The Growth Ponzi Scheme [ST03] · Not Just Bikes · 9:39
- The Problem With Facebook · 2veritasium · 6:59
- The Wrong Way to Set Speed Limits [ST06] · Not Just Bikes · 11:08
- Cities Aren't Loud: Cars Are Loud · Not Just Bikes · 17:08