Winning at programming competitions is a negative factor for being good on the job

Channel:pkrumins · Length:1:08 · Published:2015-04-05 · Views:67223

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A one-minute clip of Peter Norvig saying that Google found programming contest success correlates negatively or poorly with job performance. The description links to a blog post discussing it.

Why HN recommends it

Used as the go-to citation in LeetCode and hiring debates that competitive programming skill is not a good signal for hiring.

Peter Norvig discussed an analysis at Google that suggested doing well at coding contests was a negative indicator of job performance — HN, 2023

Software practice, open source & careers · Algorithms & data structures

Subtitles (excerpt)

one thing I can can share is that was surprising to me is it turned out that uh being a winner of one of these programming contests was actually a negative factor for performing well on the job which is surprising and it doesn't mean you guys should stop uh doing the contest uh but I think what it meant was everybody that gets hired at Google is is pretty good uh you know so if I just had to pick up somebody off the street I really want that contest winner I'm going to take him every time uh or her but if it's uh somebody who passed the hiring bar then they're all pretty much at the same level and maybe the ones who are used to winning the contest uh you know they're really used to going really really fast and cranking the answer out and then moving on to the next thing and uh you perform better on the job if you're a little bit more reflective and go slowly and make sure you you get things right so uh you know you can learn interesting things from the data that you wouldn't necessarily have known

On Hacker News

You did emphasize it was the best result, so it's hard to argue that you selected for it. Back in 2015 Peter Norvig discussed an analysis at Google that suggested doing well at coding contests was a negative indicator of job performance: [VIDEO] Presumably they do well at these sorts of questions, but that doesn't imply the same actual effectiveness. — nitwit005, 2023-04
There was a Google talk some years ago that brought up this same idea with regards to people who did programming contests: [VIDEO] — nitwit005, 2022-05
>were hit with antitrust litigation starting around 2010 because they were all involved in colluding to reduce the ability of devs to switch jobs I didn't know that, really interesting detail. >no one wants to admit they don't know what they are doing. Interesting perspective, though I don't know about the vodoo part. They seem to be taking the matter quite seriously, at least google does. Take t… — MichaelMoser123, 2022-01
> Obviously, each company can't blindly trust the interviewing practices of everyone's previous employer. Yet, they copycat each other on this. > after you've been programming for 10 years ...as I said, you're not desperate enough, so you become picky how you spend your time. > Companies aren't going out of their way to make it harder to hire good employees into their own companies. Lowering the … — zerr, 2020-08
As few comments already mentioned, post college, preparing for this type of thing immensely helps in job interviews. I find it very hard to clear job interviews and in 2017 alone, I appeared for ~25 job interviews. I'm very convinced that competitive programming skills gives you a leg up in job interviews. Many people may already may know this, but Peter Norvig indicated that it correlates poorly… — umbs, 2018-04

Related videos