36C3 - The ecosystem is moving

Channel:media.ccc.de · Length:43:03 · Published:2019-12-29 · Views:1760

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Moxie Marlinspike's 36C3 talk examines why distributed and decentralized technology is hard to build into consumer products, from the perspective of developing Signal. It argues that ecosystems move slowly and federation causes problems.

Why HN recommends it

Cited in decentralization and federation debates as the key talk on the practical challenges, though some found it defeatist.

A talk by Moxie at CCC deals with this exact question. — HN, 2021

Distributed systems · Cryptography · Privacy, surveillance & cybercrime

Subtitles (excerpt)

Herald: Our next speaker is the creator of Signal and he is going to tell you what he's doing right now. So the next talk is the ecosystem is moving - challenges for distributed and decentralized technology by Moxie Marlinspike. Have fun! Moxie: Hello! All right, so these three kids are playing around and they break into the barn of a farmer and they're playing around in the barn and the farmer hears something in the barn and he comes out to investigate, so the three kids have to hide and they see these three empty potato sacks in the barn, so they all jump in the potato sacks. But as the farmer comes in, they're still kind of like moving around a little bit. And so the farmer, you know, is investing in this situation and he starts walking towards one of the potato sacks and the kid inside sees what's happening and so he says meow and, you know, the farmer's like 'oh there's a cat in there', okay, you know . and so he starts looking at the other potato sack and, you know, the kid inside sees what's going on and so he's like woof and so the farmer's like 'okay there's like a dog in there' and the farmer starts looking at the third potato sack and as he gets closer the kid inside says potatoes.

On Hacker News

There's a great CCC presentation by Moxie (Signal originator) on that [VIDEO] ~summarized in text form [LINK] — blfr, 2025-01
A talk by Moxie at CCC deals with this exact question. > “ Considerations for distributed and decentralized technologies from the perspective of a product that many would like to see decentralize. > Amongst an environment of enthusiasm for blockchain-based technologies, efforts to decentralize the internet, and tremendous investment in distributed systems, there has been relatively little product… — seanieb, 2021-11
Appreciate the clarity. It helps me focus without going off on a wild tangent. The durability/independence of the protocol being a primary driver makes sense, and aligns with the design. > "no privileged party at all" > "The network should outlive the operator, function without it." I also believe these are absolute requirements for the future of groupchats. I'd argue for stronger requirements, b… — jazzz, 2026-07
Moxie (Signal Founder) gave a talk about the issues with federation at CCC in 2020, he took a crazy amount of flak for it, a lot of it from the Matrix community. Lots of the issue highlighted are in this post. [VIDEO] — seanieb, 2025-12
I saw Moxie Marlinspike's talk when it was posted on CCC's official channel [1] and was disgusted by it. The talk has been now censored and video was made private. It was one of the most defeatist talks I've ever come across when it comes to messaging and privacy. His message was basically that anything you do is pointless and that his and WhatsApp/Facebook's way is the right one. I've used Signa… — Jerry2, 2020-01

Related videos