Noam Chomsky - "The machine, the ghost, and the limits of understanding"
Channel:Andy80o · Length:1:31:53 · Published:2012-04-30 · Views:472085
Summary
Noam Chomsky's 2011 University of Oslo lecture on Newton's contributions to the study of mind. He argues Newton abandoned mechanical explanation and lowered the bar for scientific intelligibility, with consequences for the limits of human understanding. Q&A starts at 45:33.
Why HN recommends it
Recommended as a lucid, insightful lecture on the limits of human knowledge and the study of mind, one commenter calling it among the best lectures ever.
Chomsky's surprisingly insightful thinking on the limits of human knowledge, and the consequences — HN, 2022
Consciousness & cognition · Philosophy & ethics · Scientific method & science communication
Subtitles (excerpt)
Welcome everyone. I'm Olaf Elsvik. I'm director of CSMN and we are extremely happy to have Professor Noam Chomsky with us. Let me just say that he is the most quoted writer in academia alive. No no comparison at all with anybody else. And I think it's fair to say he is number one public intellectual in the world. So please Professor Chomsky the floor is yours. I'll talk some about Isaac Newton and his contributions to study of mind that he's not known for that but I think a case can be made that he did make substantial indirect but nevertheless substantial contributions. I'd like to explain why. There is a familiar view that the early scientific revolution beginning through the 17th century provided humans with limitless explanatory power and that that conclusion is established more firmly by Darwin's discoveries theory of evolution. I'm having mind specifically recent publication exposition of this view by two distinguished physicists philosophers David Albert and David Deutsch. But it's commonly held with many variants. There's a corollary. The corollary is ridicule of what's called by many philosophers mysterianism. That's the absurd notion that there are mysteries of nature that human intelligence will never able to grasp.
On Hacker News
Maybe off-topic, but Prof. Chomsky always mention how important Newton was in the history of science and how significant his giving up on the mechanical philosophy when he failed to explain gravity in a mechanical way, how "lowering the bar" was important to set a realistic direction for science. He has many lectures about it, I like this one: [VIDEO] , one of the best lectures ever. — mrwnmonm, 2021-03
Chomsky's surprisingly insightful thinking on the limits of human knowledge, and the consequences: [VIDEO] — Supermancho, 2022-09
Mechanical: the contact theory, that one thing can only affect another by being in contact with it e.g. the teeth of gears. Unfortunately, gravity ("spooky action at a distance") does not require contact, so the mechanical theory fails. Which can be stated figuratively as "the world is not a machine". "The machine, the ghost, and the limits of understanding: Newton's contributions to the study of… — hyperpallium, 2018-06
A mechanical universe was the prevailing theory at the time, because nothing else made sense. "Mechanical" meaning that for one thing to cause another, it had to be in physical contact (like the teeth of a cog). That theory has since been abandoned, and everyone now accepts action at a distance - which still doesn't make any sense. Noam Chomsky - "The machine, the ghost, and the limits of underst… — hyperpallium, 2018-05
Unlikely. The main problem is that calling a tradition "non-scientific" or "not hard science" also has a pejorative meaning. And there's an unfortunate mystification of science as something other than a mode of inquiry, with its limitations and advantages. Plus, people gain funding by hitching themselves to the social respectability of science. In the case of psychology, they're studying somethin… — calibraxis, 2013-03
Related videos
- Interview with Larry Summers, Former Secretary of the Treasury | The Problem with Jon Stewart · The Problem With Jon Stewart · 7:52
- The Quantum Conspiracy: What Popularizers of QM Don't Want You to Know · Google TechTalks · 1:03:43
- George Lakoff: Moral Politics · University of California Television (UCTV) · 58:57
- Justice: What's The Right Thing To Do? Episode 01 "THE MORAL SIDE OF MURDER" · Harvard University · 54:56
- What Bodies Think About: Bioelectric Computation Outside the Nervous System - NeurIPS 2018 · The Artificial Intelligence Channel · 52:06
- James Burke Connections, Ep. 1 "The Trigger Effect" · DRS_Education · 49:22
- We Were Taught to Call Death a Blessing · CGP Grey · 12:43
- Alain de Botton: Status Anxiety · Alain de Botton · 2:23:07
- Music and Life - Alan Watts · seandulac · 2:23
- Hamming, "You and Your Research" (June 6, 1995) · securitylectures · 44:02
- Why Being Delusional is a Superpower · Veritasium · 12:04
- Is Most Published Research Wrong? · Veritasium · 12:22
- Richard Feynman Fire · nebulajr · 4:43
- Analogy as the Core of Cognition · Stanford · 1:08:37
- Powers of Ten™ (1977) · Eames Office · 9:01
- The Egg - A Short Story · Kurzgesagt – In a Nutshell · 8:06