Alan Watts - On Prickles and Goo

Channel:Jamie Anderson · Length:2:35 · Published:2012-12-15 · Views:57662

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A short animated excerpt of Alan Watts describing 'prickles' (rigorous, scientific types) and 'goo' (soft, spiritual types). He argues the real division is between prickly goo and gooey prickles.

Why HN recommends it

HN uses it as shorthand for the divide between systematizing and humanistic outlooks, applied to arguments about science, society and language.

I wish we (academia, and society as a whole) would stop treating science and human concerns as prickles and goo[1]. — HN, 2017

Philosophy & ethics · Religion, belief & skepticism

Subtitles (excerpt)

[Music] you see in in the history of philosophy and poetry and art we always find The Interchange of two personality types which I call prickles and goo the L people are Advocates of intellectual cupinis they want a rigor they want precise statistics and they have a certain clipped attitude in their voices and you know this very well in academic circles where there are people who are always edgy like that and they accuse other people of being disgustingly vague and mmic and mystical but the vague miasmic and mystical people accuse the prickly people of being mere skeletons with no Flesh on their bones and they say to you you just rattle you're not really a human being you know the words but you don't know the music and so therefore if you belong to the prickly type you hope that the ultimate constituent of matter is particles if you belong to the guey type you hope its waves if you uh prickly you're a classicist and if you're gooey you're a romanticist and going back into medieval philosophy if you're prickly you're a nominalist if you're guoy you're a realist but we know very well that this natural universe is neither prickles not goo exclusively it's gooey prickles and prickly goo and

On Hacker News

It's such a wonderful thing to be reminded of how silly it is to take language seriously. IMO it's prickles and goo[1] all the way down - and the prickles help us share meaning and exchange information, but there is no project of exactitude to be completed. The hubris it takes to maintain the view that we can just keep figuring things out if we are rational enough is also sometimes overwhelming t… — bobson381, 2026-01
> "I will skip the rest of what you have written for now to first address this fundamental misunderstanding, I might get back to it when we have cleared this up. I agree that those two statements are not the same. But neither is the standpoint of science generally. "We don't know, at least not yet" does not mean "we don't know but we will know", it means "we don't know and we don't know whether w… — ZenoArrow, 2017-12
"I hope you share my intuition that utilitiarianism is an unusually thing-oriented and systematizing moral system, and that this gestures at the same large but hard-to-explain difference as the other two results." I do not. Utilitarianism, at its core, is the exact opposite of "thing-oriented" - it treats rightness of action as a function of the action's good, rather than as a property of actions… — woodruffw, 2017-08

Related videos