Isn't the purpose of work just making money?
Channel:mr1001nights · Length:5:06 · Published:2008-10-06 · Views:19853
Summary
A five-minute clip in which Erich Fromm asks whether the purpose of work is just making money. He argues that white-collar workers end up selling their personality, relating to others the way goods relate to each other on a market, and he points to creative pleasure, participation and usefulness to society as what work could offer instead.
Why HN recommends it
HN commenters repeatedly cite it for Fromm's line about selling one's personality at work, especially in threads on careers, mental health and labor.
Our main way of relating ourselves to others is like things relate themselves to things on the market. — HN, 2017
Labor, work & inequality · Psychology & human behavior · Philosophy & ethics
Subtitles (excerpt)
by meaning in itself he he he uses his work to make a living certainly that is dignified sensible and necessary yes uh but that is not quite enough to make one happy if one spends eight hours a day in something which in itself has no meaning and interest except that one gains money from It Well by meaning an interest in work uh maybe I'm pressing this unnecessarily hard what specifically do you mean when a man works at a factory with a monkey wrench let us say what meaning what what deeper meaning are you looking for well there is a creative pleasure which for instance the Artisan in the Middle Ages or in a country like Mexico still to do has namely the pleasure of creating something now you find quite a few skilled workers who still have that pleasure uh maybe in a steel mill maybe a worker who uh works with a complicated machine he has a sense that he's creating something but if you take a Salesman who sells a useless commodity he feels like a fraud and he hates his commodity like something but you say a useless commodity if he sells toothbrushes or automobiles telion well useless is a relative term for instance if in order to make his quarter he has to make people buy things of which he knows they shouldn't buy
On Hacker News
> Our main way of relating ourselves to others is like things relate themselves to things on the market. We want to exchange our own personality, or as one says sometimes, our "personality package", for something. Now, this is not so true for the manual workers. The manual worker does not have to sell his personality. He doesn't have to sell his smile. But what you might call the "symbol pushers"… — johnnyworker, 2024-01
> work is asking much more, not physically but in terms of behaviors and beliefs > Our main way of relating ourselves to others is like things relate themselves to things on the market. We want to exchange our own personality, or as one says sometimes, our "personality package", for something. Now, this is not so true for the manual workers. The manual worker does not have to sell his personality… — howaboutnope, 2021-08
> Our main way of relating ourselves to others is like things relate themselves to things on the market. We want to exchange our own personality, or as one says sometimes, our "personality package", for something. Now, this is not so true for the manual workers. The manual worker does not have to sell his personality. He doesn't have to sell his smile. But what you might call the "symbolpushers" … — PavlovsCat, 2019-02
> Jeff Schmidt demonstrates that the workplace is a battleground for the very identity of the individual, as is graduate school, where professionals are trained. He shows that professional work is inherently political, and that professionals are hired to subordinate their own vision and maintain strict "ideological discipline." I'll need to read that book, thanks. In the meantime, I was also remi… — musage, 2018-04
> Our main way of relating ourselves to others is like things relate themselves to things on the market. We want to exchange our own personality, or as one says sometimes, our "personality package", for something. -- Erich Fromm ( [VIDEO] ) > The danger of computers becoming like humans is not as great as the danger of humans becoming like computers. -- Konrad Zuse And when Picasso said that comp… — thinkfurther, 2017-06
Related videos
- 1. Introduction to Human Behavioral Biology · Stanford · 57:14
- Essential Ideas for Parents · Jason Salotti · 2:51:43
- The Century of the Self (Full Adam Curtis Documentary) · David Lessig · 3:54:44
- Justice: What's The Right Thing To Do? Episode 01 "THE MORAL SIDE OF MURDER" · Harvard University · 54:56
- What Happened to Horses Is Happening to Us · CGP Grey · 15:00
- We Were Taught to Call Death a Blessing · CGP Grey · 12:43
- Randy Pausch's Last Lecture: Achieving Your Childhood Dreams · Carnegie Mellon University · 1:16:27
- Winners Take All | Anand Giridharadas | Talks at Google · Talks at Google · 1:00:56
- Alain de Botton: Status Anxiety · Alain de Botton · 2:23:07
- Controlling Your Dopamine For Motivation, Focus & Satisfaction · Andrew Huberman · 2:16:31
- Music and Life - Alan Watts · seandulac · 2:23
- The Century of the Self - Part 1: "Happiness Machines" · JustAdamCurtis · 58:46
- The Coming Collapse of the Middle Class with Elizabeth Warren · University of California Television (UCTV) · 57:37
- RSA ANIMATE: Drive: The surprising truth about what motivates us · Royal Society of Arts · 10:48
- Why Being Delusional is a Superpower · Veritasium · 12:04
- This is how you treat ADHD based off science, Dr Russell Barkley part of 2012 Burnett Lecture · Adhd Videos · 13:46