Why is light slower in glass? - Sixty Symbols

Channel:Sixty Symbols · Length:16:30 · Published:2013-07-11 · Views:848107

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Professor Mike Merrifield of Nottingham explains in a mostly uncut conversation why light travels slower in glass. He treats light as a wave and describes how the material's electrons produce secondary waves that combine to slow it.

Why HN recommends it

HN cites it whenever the popular absorb-and-re-emit explanation comes up, as a source for the wave-interference account.

This reminds me of this Sixty Symbols video which explains why light is slower in media such as glass than in a vacuum — HN, 2019

Fundamental physics · Everyday physics & science demos

Subtitles (excerpt)

okay so here's the situation two 60 symbols professors professor marfield and Professor mariatti both got in touch saying they wanted to talk about why the speed of light seemed to slow down through glass essentially about refraction so normally what would happen I'd interview both of them do some editing chop it all together and make one video but we're going to do something different this time I'm going to show you both interviews pretty much unedited except for a few little cosmetic changes and cutting out a few of my questions where you didn't really need to hear my question and I'm going to let you watch them both this video is professor marfield and very shortly you'll be able to watch the one from Professor mariati I want to do a video about refractive index uh n um because it actually has a symbol apart from anything else but also because it's something where we've done quite a lot of videos which mention refractive index and we talk about the speed of light when it's going through a medium through glass or something like that and we talk about the speed of light slow down and invariably when we do that there's this sort of firestorm in the comments to the video all about people say ah but photons always

On Hacker News

This reminds me of this Sixty Symbols video which explains why light is slower in media such as glass than in a vacuum: [VIDEO] The incoming light wave causes an avalanche of secondary waves through electromagnetically perturbing the individual atoms, and the superposition of all these results in a wave that seems to travel slower than the speed of light. — 7373737373, 2019-12
Both ideas are incorrect. Bouncing around would be random and the outgoing light would be scattered (as in matte reflections) in all directions. Absorbtion simply destroys the original light. If photons are mostly absorbed, we call that “a wall” or ”a fog”, not “a transparent medium”, which to be transparent shouldn’t have electrons whose energy level differences correspond to a photon’s wave len… — wruza, 2021-09
> Well, actually, the speed of light is constant, it just takes time to ping-pong around a lattice/gas. Photons hit particles, get absorbed, and re-emitted, which causes an effective slowdown at a larger scale. A gas is just vacuum with particles floating around in it. When photons travel between those particles, they are traveling at c. The effective slowdown is determined by the lattice/gas, an… — vecter, 2020-12
Absorption and re-emission are probabilistic, so you'd expect experiments to show a spread distribution of propagation times, deflection angles, etc that aren't actually observed. The explanation gets into looking at light as a wave. [VIDEO] [LINK] — andreareina, 2020-11
downvoted because time traveling through a medium vs traveling through curved space are not anywhere near the same underlying principles[0]. The implication being suggested is - if I was trapped in a block of plastic or... underwater, I would experience time different compared to someone standing on land just because "c" is slower. Clearly not the case. To be specific, when "the speed of light" i… — irjustin, 2020-08

Related videos