Why Web Filters Don't Work: Penistone and the Scunthorpe Problem

Channel:Tom Scott · Length:3:37 · Published:2016-06-06 · Views:3644973

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Tom Scott visits Penistone to explain the Scunthorpe problem, showing why naive web and profanity filters block innocent words.

Why HN recommends it

The go-to explainer whenever content filters wrongly flag innocent words, well made and short.

He talks about how it's impossible to implement with all edge-cases, easy to circumvent — HN, 2020

Software architecture & design · Free speech, censorship & civil liberties

Subtitles (excerpt)

Parents: this video references very strong language. You may want to watch it first to decide whether it's right for you and your children. This is the lovely South Yorkshire village of Penistone. "Penistone." Probably once meant 'the village near the hill', but now it's... well, it's an unfortunate name. And they know it. Penistone. And yes, it causes problems sometimes, whenever some programmer decides to just outright ban certain words without thinking where else they might appear. Suddenly, you're not talking about Penistone, you're talking about "P****tone". And you might think, no programmer's going to be that careless, but it's happened a lot. There are many incidents, throughout the history of the web, about people and towns with all sorts of unusual names being filtered or rejected. It's generally known as the Scunthorpe problem, but I figured it was better to film this in Penistone because, first, the joke is so much less rude, and second, there's really no reason for anyone ever to go to Scunthorpe. Nope. Nope, nope, nope, nope nope nope nope nope. These days, programmers generally use a more lenient approach. We've learned that humans are creative. Endlessly creative. Block words? We'll add spaces or change one letter to something that sounds similar.

On Hacker News

There is a video [0] about this censoring-"problem" by Youtuber Tom Scott. He talks about how it's impossible to implement with all edge-cases, easy to circumvent and thus usually not a good idea. Fittingly, the video is filmed in Peniston. [0] [VIDEO] — thepete2, 2020-05
Tom Scott did a video on this: Why Web Filters Don't Work: Penistone and the Scunthorpe Problem - [VIDEO] It's well done, like the rest of his content. — colemannugent, 2017-04
With Tom Scott in particular, there’s a number of his videos that are kinda eerie to watch now with today’s LLM context eg. [VIDEO] — varun_ch, 2026-08
Penistone and Scunthorpe and now Memphis. [VIDEO] As much as I dislike Twitter (I only really use it for work reasons) they are in a no win situation. They either moderate what people post with a flawed system that will never be 100% or be hounded by the "Why won't anyone think of the children" group. — Crosseye_Jack, 2021-03

Related videos