Problems with gas stovetops | weak, dirty and dangerous

Channel:Adam Ragusea · Length:12:36 · Published:2021-10-04 · Views:926775

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Food YouTuber Adam Ragusea argues that gas stovetops are weaker than electric burners, dirty to clean, and a health risk from indoor air pollution. He cites Consumer Reports ratings and a literature review on gas stove health effects.

Why HN recommends it

Cited as an accessible overview of the case against gas cooktops in threads on cooking, induction and indoor air quality.

Great coverage of this entire issue — HN, 2022

Power grid, heating & buildings · Cooking & food

Subtitles (excerpt)

Hey, can I tell you about my gas problem? Gas burning stovetops. There's a lot of problems with them. I mean, there's a lot of good things about them too, but you always hear about the good things. The biggest good thing is that they are responsive, meaning you ignite them and they're instantly hot. You throttle them down, they instantly cool off. At its core, it's a very simple mechanism. It's a pipe. On one end of the pipe, there is a highly combustible and relatively clean-burning hydrocarbon, and on the other end of the pipe, there is a fire. And then midway through the pipe, there's a valve that opens and closes it. The more you open the valve, the more fuel pours into the fire. And it's a literal fire right here in your home. So, it's romantic in that way. The original cooking over an open fire, right here in your home. I get it. I was excited when I moved into this house and this house came with a really nice, really expensive gas burning stovetop. I hadn't had a gas stovetop since this really sketch apartment that I lived in briefly in college. I was excited to try it. Here in the United States, electric ranges are twice as common and as gas ranges, according to these estimates from the federal government.

On Hacker News

[VIDEO] - Great coverage of this entire issue [LINK] - Gas VS Induction [LINK] - Gas VS Induction Tl;dr over 50% of heat from a gas stove ends up in the environment. Nearly 100% of the energy from an induction cook top ends up in the pot. — com2kid, 2022-02
An induction cooktop and electric pressure cooker certainly makes a gas connection for the kitchen unnecessary. There's an interesting video from Adam Rageusa on how bad gas cooktops are: [VIDEO] I think that gas cooktops and open-air cooking vessels are just used frequently because they're easy to show off on cooking shows... Its hard to make a Youtube video on things cooking in a sealed pressur… — Factorium, 2021-10
> One of your sources is selling cook tops Yes, both gas and electric. See also their video "Induction Cooking: Pros and Cons - Part 1": * [LINK] And "Induction vs Pro Gas Cooking: Pros & Cons": * [LINK] > There is nothing wrong with natural gas - other than it's trendy to push electric currently. And the fact that it's highly inefficient and throws oodles of heat into your kitchen. See also perh… — throw0101a, 2023-07
Cooking with natural gas is thought by some people to be very good, but food YouTuber Adam Ragusea is not a fan of it in the home he recently moved into: * [VIDEO] — throw0101a, 2022-03

Related videos