The HYPERLOOP Will Never Work, Here's Why

Channel:Adam Something · Length:10:31 · Published:2021-05-07 · Views:1909812

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Adam Something argues that the Hyperloop is impractical, covering the costs and engineering problems of running trains in a near vacuum compared with conventional rail and metros. The description admits some wrong numbers in the original cut.

Why HN recommends it

Cited as a concise critique of Hyperloop feasibility whenever the idea comes up.

Some details by Adam Something on the technology itself — HN, 2022

Transit, cities & urban planning · Civil engineering & construction

Subtitles (excerpt)

the hyperloop is the third thing elon musk is famous for following closely behind tesla and spacex but the thing is vacuum trains are a century-old idea already and elon musk's idea the air-cushion-based system the hockey table in a vacuum tube it's just not a viable solution and so when elon musk made the idea open source and then let all these private companies start messing with it predictably all of them abandoned the air cushion technology all of them now use maglev with that it's safe to say that elon musk has contributed absolutely nothing to this project he just threw the idea out there with great fanfare made it open source and then let some private companies do whatever the hell they want who then immediately broke away from the air cushion tech because it was a bad idea and believe it or not this exact same thing has already happened in the second half of the 20th century have you heard about the french iro train it was this brand new ultra-fast air-cushion-based train because back then you were allowed to call these things trains which promised to revolutionize transportation grandiose plans were made working prototypes were built and then fast forward a few years and no one was talking about it and why was

On Hacker News

> When does the next hyperloop leave SF for Tokyo? Never, the whole world has been building more efficient and cost-effective transportation such as high speed rail. Some details by Adam Something on the technology itself: "The HYPERLOOP Will Never Work, And Here's Why" < [VIDEO] > — fabianhjr, 2022-01
But one of the biggest issues I've seen regarding the hyperloop is the near vacuum costing and polluting more than a conventional metro, let alone being slower to shuffle total people than a metro, and more overall more expensive than a metro. For reference: [0] [VIDEO] While this isn't explicitly about the hyperloop, it gives a good similar line with relation to the hyperloop [1] [LINK] — throwaway946513, 2021-11
Hyperloop is very much a con job. "Full Self Driving is just a year away" is very much a con job. The cybertruck is a con job. The Tesla Semi is a con job. The tesla robot is a con job. [LINK] [LINK] [LINK] [LINK] [LINK] Mark Spiegel: Elon Musk is ‘a pathological liar’ [LINK] The Fake Futurism of Elon Musk [LINK] DEBUNKING ELON MUSK Pt1 [LINK] The HYPERLOOP Will Never Work, And Here's Why [VIDEO] — HyperSane, 2022-10

Related videos