Why Western Designs Fail in Developing Countries
Channel:Design Theory · Length:27:36 · Published:2024-06-30 · Views:1766687
Summary
A design essay on why products designed in Western contexts often fail when deployed in developing countries. It covers expert blindness and cultural assumptions, with examples such as malaria nets and the One Laptop Per Child project.
Why HN recommends it
Commenters cite it to explain expert blindness and the difficulty of solving problems from inside your own cultural context.
explains a general problem (that of trying to solve problems that are more prevalent elsewhere in the world, from within your own cultural context) — HN, 2024
UX & UI design · Product & industrial design · Social issues & culture
Subtitles (excerpt)
why is it so hard for talented designers to make great products for developing countries check out this infant incubator a clever design made almost entirely out of car parts the headlights provide heat dashboard fans help with circulation and Signal lights act as emergency alarms it's 97% less expensive than a standard incubator this clever design keeps premature babies warm and would save millions of lives across the developing world it was ranked number one in Time magazine's 50 best itions of the year but the neon nurture incubator never made it into hospitals in fact the only baby ever placed inside the device was the one during this promotional photo shoot how can such a highly praised design fail so spectacularly the problem was not with the technology the idea was actually really smart in developing countries even the most advanced Tech will break down if you don't have the components or technicians to repair it but spare car parts and skilled mechanics are available all across the developing world the problem was that the designers were from the US and they missed some major cultural nuances they probably thought hey people in developing countries improvise with makeshift materials all the time
On Hacker News
It was this line of thinking which lead to the One Laptop Per Child failure. See "Why do Western Designs fail in Developing Countries" - [VIDEO] OLPC is discussed from ~9 minutes in, but the whole thing is relevant. OLPC started when Seymour Papert and Nicholas Negroponte went to Senegal to teach people to code, and found that there was no good reason to learn to code if you live in rural Senegal… — jodrellblank, 2025-02
>If you have enough funding, Malaria is preventable. It requires more than funding to solve the problem. Sorry that my source is a YouTube video, but [VIDEO] explains a general problem (that of trying to solve problems that are more prevalent elsewhere in the world, from within your own cultural context) and gives malaria as an example. People in malaria-afflicted countries, given free insecticid… — zahlman, 2024-10
> On the command line, the context is obvious. You are in the context While I share the opinion that the command line is _the one true way_ of computing, I don't think this is really all that true. Computers are alien. GUIs are alien. CLIs are alien. Everything is learned. Everything is experience. Everything is culture. Learning, experience, and culture blind us from the experience of the novice… — xk3, 2024-07
Related videos
- Why the Dutch Wait Less at Traffic Lights · Not Just Bikes · 10:34
- Joe Armstrong & Jeremy Ruston - Intertwingling the Tiddlywiki with Erlang | Code Mesh LDN 18 · Code Sync · 44:38
- Arcologies · Isaac Arthur · 28:43
- The paradox of choice | Barry Schwartz | TED · TED · 20:23
- DjangoCon 2008 Keynote: Cal Henderson · Google for Developers · 1:02:43
- The Most IMPORTANT Video You'll Ever See (part 1 of 8) · wonderingmind42 · 9:17
- Self-filling water bottle: BUSTED! · Thunderf00t · 16:52
- Why Grocery Shopping is Better in Amsterdam · Not Just Bikes · 3:46
- The surprising science of happiness | Dan Gilbert · TED · 21:20
- Life is easy. Why do we make it so hard? | Jon Jandai | TEDxDoiSuthep · TEDx Talks · 15:10
- The Dutch Solution for Safer Sidewalks - Continuous Sidewalks · Not Just Bikes · 3:44
- Colonizing Mars · Isaac Arthur · 34:32
- The Most Powerful Computers You've Never Heard Of · Veritasium · 20:12
- a better way to count · jan Misali · 18:01
- Tiffany: The Name That Cheats Death · CGP Grey · 8:56
- [EPILEPSY WARNING] How fast should an unoptimized terminal run? · Molly Rocket · 51:03
- I'll Let Myself In: Tactics of Physical Pen Testers · Wild West Hackin' Fest · 44:55
- America Always Gets This Wrong (when building transit) · Not Just Bikes · 15:27
- The Trains that Subsidize Suburbia - GO Transit Commuter Rail · Not Just Bikes · 15:49
- Why This Channel Exists (and why I hate Houston) · Not Just Bikes · 17:02