How Trees Bend the Laws of Physics

Channel:Veritasium · Length:7:22 · Published:2012-10-30 · Views:4975505

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Veritasium explains how trees lift water from roots to the top of tall trunks, using transpiration pull and the negative pressure that liquid water can sustain. It explains why trees do not need pumps or valves.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters recommend it as one of Veritasium's best videos and one that has aged well.

I recommend watching, I think it's one of the best veritasium Dereck has ever produced. — HN, 2026

Fundamental physics · Everyday physics & science demos · Animals & nature

Subtitles (excerpt)

Sometimes the simplest questions have the most amazing answers. Like how can trees be so tall? It's a question that doesn't even seem like it needs an answer. Trees just are tall. Some of them are over 100 meters. Why should there be a height limit? I'll tell you why. Tress need to transport water from their roots up into their topmost branches in order to survive. And that is no trivial task. There is a limit to the height that water can be sucked up a tube - it's 10 meters. If you suck on a long vertical straw, the water will go no higher than 10 meters. At this point there will be a perfect vacuum at the top of the straw and the water will start to boil spontaneously. For a tree to raise water 100 meters, it would have to create a pressure difference of 10 atmospheres. How would trees do that? When I posed this conundrum, a lot of people said the answer is transpiration. And that's when water evaporates from the leaf, pulling up the water molecules behind it. Now that's clearly a mechanism a tree can use to create suction, but it doesn't help us overcome this 10 meter limit. The lowest the pressure can go is a pure vacuum, which I imagine is not happening inside of tree leaves, right?

On Hacker News

> all it should take is a system of valves, That would work, but it's not how to works apparently. According to this veritasium video, it's because of "negative pressure" aka tension. [VIDEO] I recommend watching, I think it's one of the best veritasium Dereck has ever produced. — bnegreve, 2026-07
[VIDEO] It's an old video, more than ten years ago, but it aged well IMHO. I re-watched it and re-learned things I have forgotten. — _nalply, 2023-11
Just recently watched a Veritasium video on how trees get water from the roots to the top of the tree, and it's pretty awesome: [VIDEO] — linsomniac, 2019-07
This is an interesting video with an alternate explanation - the pressure required to get water to the top of the tree. Normally you can only suck a water column up 10 meters, and that's using a perfect vacuum - but trees can grow higher than that. The secret sauce is that in a liquid rather than a gas, you can have a negative pressure. [VIDEO] — vacri, 2013-01
... May we have the solution to the questions, also? I went through the concours too but I am very rusty. See also Veritasium on that topic: [VIDEO] — Arodex, 2026-07

Related videos