Freeman Dyson on the Global Warming Hysteria April, 2015

Channel:1000frolly PhD · Length:22:47 · Published:2015-04-06 · Views:470769

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A 2015 interview in which physicist Freeman Dyson, then 91, argues that global warming concerns are exaggerated, that CO2 is beneficial and that climate models oversimplify complex systems. It is posted on a channel that opposes climate consensus.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters point to it as a prominent physicist's skeptical counter-view, usually when someone asks for dissenting opinions.

He explains his position quite coherently — HN, 2020

Climate science & climate change · Climate policy, solutions & debate

Subtitles (excerpt)

welcome to conversations that matter Mike today we're having another of our conversations with an eminent scientist from Princeton University let's talk a little bit about who Our Guest is today today we'll hear from Freeman Dyson he's a 91-year-old mathematical physicist one of the most renowned scientists in the United States been around for six decades he an extraord mind talking to one of our previous guests who went you're talking to who like to say that he has a big brain would be an understatement that's right and this is someone who actually works in the same building uh at Princeton that Einstein worked in and interestingly enough not only works in that building but he was actually there when Einstein was there I know it's extraordinary you go into the building there's this bust of Albert Einstein and the address is one Einstein driveing it Dawns on you that this is a place where some rather extraordinary thinking happens extraordinary and in his own words subversive science contrarian contrarian yeah Freeman Dyson believes we ought to be using science as a weight up in the apple cart and particularly teach young people that science can be an act of rebellion uh positive Rebellion you know

On Hacker News

He was an expert as much as anyone. From his wiki: "Around 1979 Dyson worked with the Institute for Energy Analysis on climate studies. This group, under Alvin Weinberg's direction, pioneered multidisciplinary climate studies, including a strong biology group. Also during the 1970s, Dyson worked on climate studies conducted by the JASON defense advisory group.[26]" He held the view that CO2 was m… — chrisco255, 2020-04
Freeman Dyson did speak out against climate alarmism. He provides some insightful counterpoints to the prevailing APW narrative, particularly about taking models on faith & the provisional nature of science. Given he was directly involved with some of the initial climate models, it's an interesting take on how models of complex nonlinear systems often oversimplify reality with assumptions. It see… — briantakita, 2020-02
A fascinating talk, and a counter viewpoint from a top physicist: "Freeman Dyson on the Global Warming Hysteria" [VIDEO] — Radim, 2018-04
Number one they're not all in agreement. Number two, outright, science does not work on consensus. The only reason climate relies on consensus is because they cannot validate their models. They are stuck on the hypothesis step of the scientific method. It doesn't matter how many people you get to agree with your hypothesis. Without empirical experimentation, it proves nothing. You cannot beat cha… — chrisco255, 2020-04
Here's an interview of Freeman Dyson in 2015 re: APW & faith in models of complex nonlinear systems. Also goes into solar activity (electric, magnetic, & ion ejections) as a driver of climate change. Note that CMIP6 includes particle forcing to its model. CMIP5 & earlier versions did not include particle forcing. [VIDEO] — briantakita, 2020-02

Related videos