Guilty until proven innocent.

Channel:JCS - Criminal Psychology · Length:17:17 · Published:2020-10-08 · Views:22873552

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A compilation of police interrogations of innocent suspects who behave in very different ways yet are treated as guilty. It illustrates how interrogation tactics and detectives' assumptions can distort the truth.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters use it to show that behavior in interrogations is not a reliable sign of guilt and that police lie to innocent people.

It shows two example interrogations of innocent suspects, each displaying completely different behaviour. — HN, 2021

Law, policing & justice · Psychology & human behavior

Subtitles (excerpt)

With respect to interrogation analysis, it's no secret the benefit of hindsight gives you a considerable advantage when evaluating information. When you know a subject is guilty, it allows you to exclusively look for guilty behavior. The knowledge of outcome highlights the imperatives while stripping away non-essentials and this allows you to calculate certain things that would otherwise be overlooked by cause of your own doubt. Hindsight is 2020. Everyone is well aware of this apherism. And what's fascinating is that it not only applies but is far more compatible to the innocent than it is to the guilty. The reason for this is because the information you have to scrutinize is reduced when dealing with innocent subjects. When you remove the versatile factors of misdirection and trickery, you're left with relatively straightforward behavior in comparison. Of course, the argument that everyone is different and can react in a different manner has merit. Human beings are unique and there will always be exceptions to every rule, especially when you take into consideration that trauma can cause atypical behavior. Yet, atypical behavior and guilty behavior are generally distinguished from each other with relative ease.

On Hacker News

This video is relevant: [VIDEO] It's about interrogation, and the common notion that a guilt can be inferred by the suspect's behaviour. It shows two example interrogations of innocent suspects, each displaying completely different behaviour. — oftenwrong, 2021-03
If you're interested there are plenty of interrogation videos on yt, some by the FBI are particularly interesting. Sometimes they have a pretty good case but getting a confession tremendously speed up the process so they lie to get confessions. They also can lie to trigger responses and see how the suspect react, guilty people seem to react in way different ways than innocent ones. It's obviously… — lm28469, 2021-07
>It's not really about leverage or power. It's more of a strategic setting where the winning move is either to be 100% truthful (if you're innocent - and even JCS acknowledges this!) or not to play. It seems to be the opposite. This JCS video shows 100% non-guilty people being 100% truthful, and their truthful statements are regularly seen as further evidence of their criminality: [VIDEO] Whether… — meowface, 2021-06

Related videos