The Battle of Midway 1942: Told from the Japanese Perspective (1/3)

Channel:Montemayor · Length:41:46 · Published:2019-04-27 · Views:19733408

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Part one of Montemayor's animated-map documentary on the Battle of Midway, told using only the information available to the Japanese side. It focuses on Nagumo's dilemma.

Why HN recommends it

HN recommends it for its information-dense maps and voice-over and for showing how commanders decide with limited information.

This youtube series telling the Battle of Midway from Japanese perspective — HN, 2021

World history · Military history & warfare

Subtitles (excerpt)

It's been six months since the attack on Pearl Harbor and so far the war has been triumphant for the Empire of Japan They had achieved a string of victories across the Pacific and had captured many resource rich territories However, Japan still found herself in a difficult position Despite all of their successes, their biggest opponent, the United States, had yet to show any signs of surrendering - this was worrisome. Japan needed to end the war quickly before the US, with its mighty industrial strength, ultimately defeated them. So, what Japan needed was to win a decisive battle - one that would demoralize the Americans and finally bring them to the negotiating table. It was considered that America's center of gravity was its Pacific Fleet, primarily its carriers. Destroy this and you destroy their will to continue the war. Therefore, the only chance Japan had a winning this war was if the American carrier fleet was destroyed. But the question was: how to provoke the carriers from leaving it's safe base at Pearl Harbor? The answer: attack an objective that the Americans wouldn't relinquish without a fight and, after much debate, it was decided that Midway would be that objective. If the Japanese attacked and invaded Midway,

On Hacker News

It wasn't as lucky as it seems. The dive bombers were able to dive straight down, almost vertically, with no risk of being shot down by the enemy Zero fighters (since they were drawn away by a previous attack). It's more lucky that they didn't attack the same targets, than that they hit their targets. Also, not directly relevant, but I'll plug this video: [VIDEO] it's great. — sillysaurusx, 2021-05
> Even with overwhelming superiority during WW2, the US damn near lost their first attempt to invade Japan. > Ditto for Japan attacking Midway, and every other decisive battle. What you're missing here is the fog of war. When decisions are viewed through what information was available to the decision-makers, it paints a far more relatable picture. No one was stupid at Midway. Have a look at this … — philistine, 2022-02
For midway, you might want to watch: [VIDEO] > Ineffective dive bombing at Midway? It was the only thing that was effective! Poorly executed would be a better term. They succeeded by almost pure luck. Two different squadrons managed to accidentally attack in different directions at the same time while the Japanese carriers had fully fueled and armed airplanes in their hangars waiting for an openi… — kayodelycaon, 2021-12
The amount of luck involved in the US victory at Midway is astonishing. About the only part of it not due to luck was the codebreaking that tipped off the US about the coming Midway attack, the heroic efforts of the dock workers in getting the damaged Yorktown fixed and back to sea in 72hrs, and persistence of the aviators who finally broke through the Japanese defenses and hit the carriers. This… — SkyMarshal, 2021-05
This youtube series telling the Battle of Midway from Japanese perspective (ie. only using the information available to them)is interesting [VIDEO] [LINK] [LINK] — rusanu, 2021-04

Related videos