What Happened When This City Banned Housing Investors

Channel:Oh The Urbanity! · Length:9:15 · Published:2023-09-24 · Views:95903

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Oh The Urbanity! tests the theory that banning housing investors would fix affordability, using Rotterdam's ban as a case study. The video finds mixed results.

Why HN recommends it

Cited as a real-world experiment showing that banning investors did not lower purchase prices and may have raised rents.

Rotterdam did just this, and the effect was that the price to purchase a house did not measurably decrease, and that rents rose. — HN, 2023

Microeconomics & behavioral economics · Labor, work & inequality · Transit, cities & urban planning

Subtitles (excerpt)

There’s a theory of housing that says the problem we’re facing is fundamentally not a lack of homes or restrictions on building and density. Instead, we face a scourge of investors who buy homes not to live in but to rent out, taking away options from aspiring home buyers and forcing them into renting. As one comment on our channel argued, “the investors are the prime cause of this housing crisis lets stop the gaslighting and verbal gymnastics”. What we really need, then, is to encourage homeownership and clamp down on investors who outbid first-time-homebuyers. “Take out the demand from investors and you have more than enough supply. Which drives costs down.”, according to another commenter on one of our videos. Well, clamping down on investors is exactly what Rotterdam in the Netherlands tried to do — here’s how it turned out. In 2019, almost 20% of homes in the Netherlands were bought with the intention of renting them out, climbing to around 30% in major urban areas. In 2021 the Dutch government introduced a law allowing municipalities to ban buying a home to rent it out, in order to give regular homebuyers a leg up over investors. Rotterdam was the first major municipality in the country to make use of

On Hacker News

> Economics is the worst social science, an economist is never considered wrong, only of a different “school of economics”. Economists speak as if they have authority and as if their field is objective, but at the same time have those “schools”. Is there such a thing as an unideological economist? Economics is falsifiable. For example, a bunch of folks made a prediction ("currency debasement and … — throw0101d, 2024-12
What was the controllable with Eddington? * [LINK] Einstein's models made a prediction, people 'tested' that prediction in Nature, and it turned out accurate. General theory has made other predictions, and empirical observations have found them to be accurate as well. Plenty of "real" science is/was done outside of controlled experiments in a lab. A phenomena was going to happen (e.g., tax law ch… — throw0101c, 2023-10
> But other than zoning it seems it would help more if the government would step in to disallow large leasing companies buying up giant swathes of the housing stock just to flip into rentals. There was a timely video about this yesterday from Oh the Urbanity: [VIDEO] Summary is that Rotterdam did just this, and the effect was that the price to purchase a house did not measurably decrease, and tha… — ryukafalz, 2023-09

Related videos