The Expert (Short Comedy Sketch)

Channel:Lauris Beinerts · Length:7:34 · Published:2014-03-23 · Views:33069485

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A comedy sketch of a business meeting in which an engineer, the expert, is asked to do impossible things like draw red lines with blue ink.

Why HN recommends it

Shared constantly as a painfully accurate depiction of absurd requirements, clueless management and estimation pressure.

Relevant clip perfectly highlighting the problems you have during requirement analysis — HN, 2021

Management, leadership & organizations · Stand-up & sketch comedy · Satire & parody

Subtitles (excerpt)

Our company has a new strategic initiative to increase market penetration, maximise brand loyalty, and enhance intangible assets. In pursuit of these objectives, we've started a new project -- for which we require 7 red lines. I understand your company can help us in this matter. Of course! Walter here will be the Project Manager. Walter, we can do this, can't we? Yes, of course. Anderson here is our expert in all matters related to drawing red lines. We brought him along today to share his professional opinion. Nice to meet you! Well, you all know me. This is Justine, our company's design specialist. Hallo... We need you to draw seven red lines. All of them strictly perpendicular; some with green ink and some with transparent. Can you do that? No. I'm afraid we -- Let's not rush into any hasty answers, Anderson! The task has been set and needs to be carried out. At the end of the day, you are an expert. The term "red line" implies the colour of the line to be red. To draw a red line with green ink is -- well if it is not exactly impossible, then it is pretty close to being impossible. What does it even mean: "impossible"? I mean, it is quite possible that there are some people, say suffering from colour blindness,

On Hacker News

I really enjoyed the post. I reminded me a lot of this Youtube video( [VIDEO] ). I understand this is a comical post but as the son of a carpenter and understanding the profession decently well I would say these are none of the questions that would be asked of a carpenter. There are however many important questions a person would need to answer to be hired as a carpenter or more likely be able to… — bmoresbest55, 2015-02
Oh snap that was some good "the expert" energy. [VIDEO] Why cant we have parallel lines that intersect. Geometry. — citizenpaul, 2025-10
If it can pass it when you ask it in a way only a coder can write, then we will still need coders. If you need to tweak your prompt until you get the correct result, then we still need coders who can tell that the code is wrong. Ask Product Managers to use ChatGPT instead of coders and they will ask for 7 red lines all perpendicular to each other with one being green. [VIDEO] — eloisant, 2023-11
Always a good time to rewatch the expert: [VIDEO] > most people are okay at describing their problems, but suck at proposing solutions Yes, it's best to focus on their problems and the consequences of proposed solutions. They shouldn't care about your caching strategy internals but they do care about whether stale info impacts their users or what scale it's reasonable to hit, or how much extra it… — IanCal, 2023-10
The third 'no' is really well shown in [VIDEO] . (A video about an expert being asked to do the impossible by people who have no idea what they are asked.) — btilly, 2023-09

Related videos