Charlie Brooker's Screenwipe - Reality TV Editing

Channel:Samusek TDS · Length:5:07 · Published:2007-03-02 · Views:1748615

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A clip from Charlie Brooker's BBC show Screenwipe showing how reality TV uses editing to manufacture emotion and narrative. It demonstrates how the same footage can be cut to give very different impressions.

Why HN recommends it

HN people cite it as a vivid demonstration of how editing shapes perception in documentaries and reality television.

here is an awesome video that shows how editing can do wonders for how we perceive things(1). — HN, 2021

Filmmaking & video production · Media, journalism & propaganda

Subtitles (excerpt)

CGI and special effects are all very well but for my money the most significant technological advances have taken place away from the screen in the world of editing video editing used to be a fairly cumbersome process more difficult than film which you could easily slice up with razor blades consequently in ye olden days there was often more Vision mixing than editing indoor scenes would be shot in a studio using several cameras and the director would cut between them creating an edit on the Fly exterior scenes used to be shot on 16 mm film because it was easier to edit that's why a lot of old shows especially comedies had such a different feel whenever they cut to an outdoor locations that's an effect that will be familiar to anyone who remembers the Peerless Faulty Towers true to subversive form Monty Python even used it as the basis for a very clever sketch I have bad news this room is surrounded by film what things changed in the early '90s when hard disc editing arrived to excite this edition of Tomorrow's World I can see all the shots here on this screen and they're instantly accessible and over here on this one this is where you build up your edited report you can swap shots over or

On Hacker News

I used to love watching documentaries but the more you watch them the more you see how most often they are biased and edited to show the authors / producers point of view. How a documentary is edited can mean the same facts and interview being used to show something being positive or totally negative. I guess it's true for all media but I've found this especially true for a lot of recent ones I'v… — superasn, 2021-09
Most mainstream documentaries are full of fluff. You can generally read the transcript of a half hour programme in a couple of minutes. I thought Charlie Brooker might have a useful segment on it, but all I could find were the not-quite-on-point, but nevertheless excellent two related segments below: [VIDEO] [LINK] — hgomersall, 2025-02
> the more you watch them aka Media literacy. > the more you see how most often they are biased What's the alternative? > ...here is an awesome video that shows how editing can do wonders for how we perceive things ... [VIDEO] That's quite good. Nice point about how better gear enabled the reality TV format. I did some radio and TV stuff as a kid. (A vocational tech program. Student radio, cable … — specialist, 2021-09
David Attenborough does not make the same style of programming that Curtis does. Curtis has a very specific world view, or world vibe, let's say whereas Attenborough does have views about the world but not much else beyond visual grandeur. His earlier stuff is definitely better than his more recent work, but I refer specifically to the hypernormalization documentary because it's absolutely full o… — mhh__, 2022-05
Charlie Brooker's Screenwipe demonstrates this perfectly, using the same footage and completely flipping the tone: [VIDEO] The prologue of This American Life episode 458, "Play the Part" provides good testimony about this process from someone who worked in editing. [LINK] Chuck Klosterman's "Sex, Drugs, and Cocoa Puffs" has a chapter on the Real World, "What Happens When People Stop Being Polite.… — brownbat, 2015-03

Related videos