Jonathan Blow: Game design: the medium is the message

Channel:CreativeMornings HQ · Length:48:26 · Published:2013-11-03 · Views:119324

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Jonathan Blow's CreativeMornings talk arguing that business models shape game design, drawing an analogy between 1970s TV and HBO and between free-to-play and premium games. He calls for games that inspire awe rather than chase constraints.

Why HN recommends it

HN cites it repeatedly in debates about in-app purchases and monetization corrupting games.

how the business model deeply corrupts the game through the metaphor of bad 70's TV shows vs HBO — HN, 2013

Game design · Indie game development

Subtitles (excerpt)

[Music] he [Music] [Applause] hey so I like to know who I'm talking to so let me figure that out uh who out here plays video games go ahead and raise your hand pretty much everybody um who out here makes video games in some capacity all right less than half but significant number of people who makes traditional video games I.E not social or casual games all right and who makes sort of some of the newer social casual Facebook iOS kind of games all right so really a minority good so not too many people are going to want to Lynch me by the end of this talk but there still may be a couple let me let me go to my presentation so um I've been a video game designer for a while now um I I work in that field it's my field of expertise and that's why I wanted to kick off this talk obviously by talking about a subject like television and not just television but a specific subgenre of Television um the hourlong drama and I have drama in sarcasm quotes for a pretty good reason as we will see um and I don't even just want to talk about television shows like this one which I enjoyed tremendously um or this one which received tremendous critical Acclaim or even this one which is enthralling a lot of people right now um but also I want to turn the

On Hacker News

Jonathan Blow (Braid and Indie Fund) recently gave an amazing presentation on the evolution of Television, and he made an interesting parallel to the evolution of games: [VIDEO] — DanielRibeiro, 2013-11
There's an interesting talk about that by Jonathan Blow, using the common phrase 'The Medium is the Message'. The eventual topic is mobile game design but he starts off with TV and how commercial and other constraints influence show (and game) design. [VIDEO] — hnick, 2020-06
While I disagree with the word dumb and find "ignorant" more suitable, your Candy Crush comparison is bad. Jonathan Blow nailed it in this presentation: [VIDEO] — emsy, 2017-05
>It is almost certain you have or are playing a game I have produced or worked on in a major capacity. Maybe for a few minutes. I like to think I'm good at analysing game mechanics, as a long time gamer and sometimes amateur game designer. So I mostly avoid F2P games. The tactics are repulsive to my tastes, and I can smell them from a mile away. When there's a choice between struggling to meet a … — aethertron, 2015-09
I've followed Jonathan Blow for a while. He has a reputation for being condescending. If you follow him a Twitter then you might come to the same conclusion. But he has given some amazing talks. [VIDEO] <-compares games to televison [LINK] [LINK] [LINK] — kelukelugames, 2015-02

Related videos