Who cares about topology? (Old version)

Channel:3Blue1Brown · Length:16:29 · Published:2016-11-04 · Views:3293694

Watch on YouTube

Summary

An older 3Blue1Brown video on why topology matters, built around the inscribed rectangle problem. It walks through how tori and Mobius strips appear in the solution. The channel later replaced it with an updated version.

Why HN recommends it

Fans name it as a favorite 3Blue1Brown video, praising its detective-story treatment of the inscribed square and rectangle problem.

A particular favourite is the one on the Inscribed Square Problem — HN, 2018

Pure mathematics · Recreational & visual math

Subtitles (excerpt)

I've got several fun things for you this video. An unsolved problem, a very elegant solution to a weaker version of the problem, and a little bit about what topology is and why people care. But before I jump into it, it's worth saying a few words on why I'm excited to share this solution. When I was a kid, since I loved math and sought out various mathy things, I would occasionally find myself in some talk or a seminar where people wanted to get the youth excited about things that mathematicians care about. A very common go-to topic to excite our imaginations was topology. We might be shown something like a mobius strip, maybe building it out of construction paper by twisting a rectangle and gluing its ends. Look, we'd be told, as we were asked to draw a line along the surface. It's a surface with just one side. Or we might be told that topologists view coffee mugs and donuts as the same thing, since each has just one hole. But these kinds of demos always left a lurking question. How is this math? How does any of this actually help to solve problems? It wasn't until I saw the problem that I'm about to show you, with its elegant and surprising solution, that I started to understand why

On Hacker News

That's really interesting. I found that I loved, similar to the occasional video numberphile does, watching Grant explain how one might realistically solve an interesting problem. A particular favourite is the one on the Inscribed Square Problem, which, although introducing some elements of topology, engages me more from the get go. He poses a problem and my curiosity keeps me engaged until the v… — thicknavyrain, 2018-07
I really like 1blue3brown, but this one didn't quite resonate with me. To me, it felt like a long winded way to make it intuitive that the point (1, 1 ... 1) has distance sqrt(n) from the origin, where n is the number of dimensions. I think there'd be move value in explaining things like 'most volume is near the edge' and 'most points are far apart'. Granted, that is less about building intuition… — rocqua, 2017-08
3Blue1Brown explanation of eigenvectors and eigenvalues is very insightful and intuitive [1]. One of my favorite videos from his channel is "Who cares about topology? (Inscribed rectangle problem)" [2]. They way a Torus and Möbius Strip come up as solution to the problem is so elegant. [1]: [LINK] [2]: [VIDEO] — yamaneko, 2017-02
Here's a nice 3blue1brown video about the easier version of the inscribed rectangle problem, that some inscribed rectangle exists: [VIDEO] And I remember thinking this was a nice overview of some aspects of the "square peg problem" (the Toeplitz conjecture): [LINK] — kmill, 2020-06

Related videos